Whiting ?

winger,centre and a scrumhalf please!!!!!!

I would give him a 5 year deal!

not sure that he deserves a 3 year contract, the way hull are going we will be giving everyone 2/3 year deals. i think a lot of the squad need to prove themselves.

manu and whiting have proved their worth so far-unsure about the rest of the ooc players

also my thoughts on it! think its a very good move!

the combination between him and Briscoe and Manu is starting to produce tries get Willie signed up and that is a very strong left side attack to build a side around. but its the right hand side which need sorting

Manu - Oh yes
Whiting - See above.
Hall - I'd keep Hall in spite of his current form on the wing.
Cusack - We all know he's going.
Dowes - If there's no one else coming through/available I'd keep (just)
Radford - Let him go
Calderwood - Keep
Houghton - Keep
Tickle - Keep

seems fair enough does that.

totally agree

I'd keep Radford and let Dowes go but agree with the rest. Tickle may be difficult to keep.

Everyone agrees the current squad is nowhere near good enough but you want us to re-sign most of them anyway.

Would only leave us with king's, raynor's, radford's and cusack's salaries to bring in at least 1 prop, 2 wingers and a centre

I agree with that, but if Radford went, and if perhaps Fitzy went also, then I wonder who Agar would play at 13?

Do you think he would go with one of Tickle/Washy/Whiting/Turner or bring in someone else?

Definitely a plaice for him!

I don't think the majority of the squad is "no-where near good enough" I feel it's unbalanced.
If Dowes stays then we wouldn't need another prop, I agree we need backs, whether we need two wingers depends on Reece's development.

I hope we reel him in.

I think that now, more than ever.

what other teams? ave a word been less than average since he did his ankle at saints years ago
?
lets sign all the rubbish for a another 3 years including the coach no ambition


we are a poor team coached poorly

give washy another 5 year deal hull lad and all that apart from hes cr@p!!!!!!
arghhhhhhh

It easy to see where we need strenghing but we also need to bring in good cover.

It's ok saying we need a half back but we can't afford to have a big name player come in.

Alot depends where agar sees players like briscoe and whiting playing.

If he sees briscoe as a winger and whiting as a centre then that's the backs sorted (if calderwood stays or we bring in a replacement).

If he wants

tansey
calderwood(new signing)
briscoe
yeaman
new signing

And whiting to the back row then we would have to lose some members of the pack.

Good news - always like Yeaman and with him being homegrown and the deal likely to have been discounted a bit for the impact of a testimonial, this was probably a no-brainer. Plus, he's the calendar king of the squad IMO.

talking sh-te now arent ye.

am i not entitled to an opinion then ??

Great news about Yeaman, we can't afford to lose players like him, one club man!

I am slightly disappointed in some ways as I would have liked to see him go to Leeds or Saints and see how good he could have been, but on a selfish note it's great to keep him.

I think its a bit unfair people saying he hasnt been the same player over the past few seasons, I think that it is simply down to Cooke leaving and the club still not signing a quality replacement. Hes not the most complicated of players, he has great upper body strengh with a good fend and runs good lines, give him something to run on to and he will break the line and score trys, he dosnt have that spark that will create something from nothing with a step or a dummy.

I dont think he will ever realise his potential here for the reasons above, but that said he strike rate is still good over the past three seasons, Im quite surprised though that he hasnt moved on to try and make another go of his international career, he has missed his last chance in my opinion by signing a three year deal, will only benifit us though.

Another average player in an average team IMO. Personally I wouldnt have been concerned if he wasnt re-signed.

great signing for us imo been one of our best this season

some people need to watch yeaman for the little things he does and not have a go when he doesnt pass

Dont get how Leeds or Rovers could of been interested as surely that would of been tapping him up illegally or are Hull FC talking rubbish to cover their own position?