You should have tried reffing, a few people nearly died!

Ohh which age group did you ref??

I was doing the Touch.

Totally agree with you, the kid had a stinker. The Messiah might be able to do something with him...but i doubt it

Hope he does the dullers.

And you was poo....

A fantastic debut for the lad, lets hope he carries it on.

One thing for certain is I think most Rovers fans will keep a look out for him now when he eventually plays for you.

Here's to more of the same on Thursday

Yes, well done Josh. Having read a few postings on this thread, I was at the academy final last year when your academy side wiped the floor with stains academy and I was thinking then - keep these youngsters and you have the makings of a new Super League dynasty - similar to the one at Leeds which has enjoyed sucess since 2004, without breaking the salary cap. (Not a swipe) I read on Sky text today that you are linked with certain Melbourne Storm players. My advice to your board would be DONT DO IT!! Have faith with the youngsters and current crop of "experienced players" and I can see that Wigan will return to the domination you enjoyed from the mid eighties.

As for Karl Pryce, sorry I just dont get it - he is pants and it is only the centres that make him look good. A bit like Ade Gardner.....

As you well know I have talked quite a lot about Josh over the past two seasons and am sure he will do well. I disagree with you however on the signings of Lima and Hoffman as I think it's good business by Wigan in that they are replacing overseas players who are at the club now so we are not stopping anyone coming through.

On Pryce, with all due respect I have probably seen a lot more of him than you have over the last two seasons. As I have stated on a few occasions I would give him one more year contract and see how he progresses. There are certainly signs IMO that he has a lot to offer to Wigan and RL IF he can fully regain his confidence and fitness.

Certainly against yourselves in the cup Scott Donald wasn't keen on taking him on.

Will Wigan allow rovers to extend the loan of josh charnley until the end of season or even sign him up for next year as he is out of contract?

I think a longer loan is a possiility. Signing him? No chance whatsoever!

but where is he going to come into play? Richards Pryce Roberts and gleeson all have international experiance and (apart from kyle pryce but soon will be if he keeps performing) and josh will just be a second choice to injurys or get runs out in cup/freindleys/salford/catalans/quins

Carmont only has a year at most in him. Richards contract is up after next season and there's no word on Pryce's contract situation.

but at rovers he is going to play week in week out

Well you can continue to have him on loan until we need him.

If Pryce is on a big wage as rumoured i would offer him reduced terms on a 1 year deal and if he says no then Charnley takes his place. I wouldnt be too worried if Pryce went and Charnley stepped into his place tomorrow.

that is right but josh needs more experiance to play for a top club like you yes we are a decent team but grand final and wembley are out of our reach at least for a few more years and your a team sat at top on sl and had a qf against leeds in cc and looks you will take league and should go to trafford

Pryce signed a 1 year extension last year under IL so I'd imagine he won't be on big money this year. If he signs another 1 year deal for next season, you can bet that won't be mega bucks either.

In the current situation, probably.

However when Welham returns and even Colbon, they should get ahead of Charnley.

(Charnley looks a top promise, but Welham has been great all year).

It would be great cover to sign Charnley again on loan next season, mind.

Left wing and left centre, Charnley has been signed as cover for Webster and Ratu in the right centre which is where he will play for the rest of this season once his loan is extended. Charlie will go onto the bench in place of Cook

Thats not too bad then. He does deserve another year to see if he can kick on as long as its on our terms. There wouldnt be much point throwing too much money at him with Charnley pushing for a place.

Once you get your centres back then Charnley wont even get in the team anyway.

Yeah, when we get them back next season

Idiot Come back when you know what to talk about

Why is he an idiot?

What he said makes sense to me.