...where do you think they would/should play it?

I can't imagine Rovers wanting the game at the KC unless there were certain conditions (I.e. Having a touchline stand perhaps). There's not really much other choice for miles then.

Whoa, lets get Friday out the way first.

^^This^^

Only playing the champions without our scrum half and best forward.

Maybe that's why he said 'IF'?

It would probably have to be Huddersfield.

Come on, discussing a hypothetical all Hull semi a day or two before both play a quarter final?

Coincidence.

Personally I would go to the KC as long as certain criteria is met ie changing rooms allocation of tickets etc.

Would much rather see a full house in hull then have to trek to Hudds on a Friday night.

What's wrong with that? I don't think we'll both go through, and I don't think we'll draw each other anyway, but you never know.

It's better to gage these opinions now then when it's too late!

When you look at the history of the two clubs, Headingley IMO would be absolutely perfect (and just imagine the atmosphere!!) but in reality I reckon either John Smith's or Keepmoat would be chosen by the RFL.

IF we had an All-Hull Semi Final then logic would say play it at the KC.

Presumably the RFL would come up with us having to play it at Warrington, with Warrington and St Helens making the short distance to Widnes!

Practically, the KC would be a suitable venue in terms of capacity and distance. To ensure neutrality tickets could be split to give each club half the ground each. Rovers record at our place is pretty good and as with most Derbies, home advantage doesn't always have much bearing on the result. It would be a great event for the city.

I hope both clubs make it through to the Semi-Finals. I think Rovers will beat Les Cats tonight and hopefully we can do the biz tomorrow night.

I can't see anyway it would be at the KC, handing a team home advantage in such an important game would never happen regardless of it being easier for fans and changes to allocation.

Keepmoat is 15k and I would have thought that would be big enough.

We practically filled the Keepmoat when we played Wakey. Keepmoat is definitely not big enough for 2 Hull clubs. "IF" it happens, it will be Hudds. but I'm a cynic and believe the 2 clubs would be kept apart in any semi draw, even re-drawing if the mistake was made. We've seen it all before

Never mind the semi final. Lets all have a day out at Wembley. Its time to put the record straight!!!

Surely if we both do make it through & do face each other Allan would let us use the KC at a knock down rate? Gift to the community & all that.

Or ram it home for good



What a horrible day that would be, winning and losing would be such a double whammy it'd be unbearable to watch.

If we both did get through , which I don't think will happen , when would people rather us face rovers . Semi or final ?

Heart says beating them to end our Wembley hoodoo would be the best feeling you could ever get as a fan...but head says both teams are very evenly matched and a defeat would pretty much finish me off!

well at the minute, it looks very unlikely with all these daft errors!!

rotterdam? or bruges?

Last place I'd have wanted to play a game is at the KC. We're feckin awful at home

On the money again Jake.