I reckon the Giants had a rough deal in terms of the decisions. Yet, despite that the reason they lost was that they collectively under-performed as a team.

Of course, that may just have been partly due to their being behind from the second minute to a try scored from an apparent knock-on. Who knows?

What I do know is the Giants are a damn good team and still could have a big say in the playoffs. Be nice to put the disappointment behind.

Sorry mate but that's rubbish, both commentators on BBC gave it as a try after watching the replays, both were extremely suprised that the try wasn't given.

ATEOTD the best team won as I have now said many times, we did not turn up and we froze on the day, but we have ref's from all over including France so why have a VR from Warrington? He may have made a human error and no-one would have focused on this as much but with him coming from Warrington it allows people to read more into it.

The RFL are incapable of making sensible decisions, do you honestly think the FA would have had a ref from Manchester for a FA Cup final between Man Utd and Chelsea?

This is the same senario and it just would not happen.

Davies also called the forward pass for your first try!

I thought it was tight but JD must have been right I suppose?

I really hope that you're not that stupid, he lives in Warrington but is from leigh and actually watches them, he has no afilliation to the club whatsoever.

Well this is only going to go one way, isn't it.

Yup, going in circles, 90% of neutrals think the VR got the calls wrong, he is a ref in the Warrington Association and where he was born is therefore irellevant, it wouldnt happen in any sport

he did get some calls wrong.

it probably made no difference to the end result.