Wires71:just_browny:
There's no evidence whatsoever that Wane would thrive outside of Wigan. Good record yes, but he only cares about Wigan and at the first sign of trouble he would blame.the 'Wire culture' rather than do anything about changing whatever that culture is. Just like Powell, who brought in all his mates like Holmes and Matautia and blamed the 'Wire culture' rather than the fact his mates were just poor players.
I agree it would be like Powell all over again. The players would sulk and get him sacked.
I like Wane and would have liked him to come here but that was always a worry. Wigan has a very different culture with a conveyor belt of young talent who are bought in to the team culture and know that egos are not tolerated, but also they had a good eye for signing quality players from outside. Wane always had a culture of guys who knew how to dig in and win big games when it counted.
Powell did well in the Cas culture which was also one of leaving your egos at the door and making shrewd good value signings. In hindsight he wasn't the right man to do a clear out and culture change here - especially as the Cas guys he brought over to try to bring Cas culture were past their best and didn't have the performances to get credibility with our existing players.
Burgess was better suited to changing the culture because he has the aura and personality to stamp himself on players who have big egos. But that gets undermined when the recruitment is bad. The quality of squad is weaker than it was in the Price era before the Powell clear out and Burgess is struggling to get performances out of a team which is very mid-table quality with some players who would struggle to get picked up by other SL teams if they left us.
I remember during the Price era I used to think our fans overrated our squad - there was frustration that we weren't winning the Grand Final because a lot of fans on here would argue that we were as good as Wigan/Saints/Catalans on paper. But I think now most of our fans accept that we're lacking in quality and there's some chaff in some positions.