1 The point is he floored O'Brien with a straight to the face and it was a straight sending off. It was a "blow" not a "push".
2 He did a cowardly thing and so what you would or wouldn't say is irrelevant. What does he say about what he did? Brave and fearless?
3 Sorry. I have watched the video and yes, you played with 10 men all game. My bad.
4. A man went down and wasn't moving, whether it turned out to be a head injury is irrelevant the point is the game should under the new rules be stopped. The team assumed play would be stopped and hesitated, which led directly to your try.
5. I'm not contradicting myself, I'm being fair to both teams. The game was indeed even, your winning margin certainly came off mistakes, and yes on the day you very much had the rub of the green. As you well know.

The ref was shocking both ways, the point where he penalised us for holding down, the pulled ferguson out and warned about holding on was laughable. I thought he lost the game early and never really recovered. Still good game to watch, hope you lot carry on and have a good season, come middle 8 time anything can happen.

My main gripe with the ref was his body language. Both sides scored a try when the defending team stopped to watch him as he went through the motions of blowing for a penalty without actually doing it. Hull KR first for the score that put them to 28 points, and then Bradford's next try was scored in much the same way.

It was a good learning experience for our lads. It confirmed some things we already know and we learned some new things.

It showed the value of a good kicking game. We just couldn't deal with those bombs and cross kicks. There was no protection for the catchers to stop the HKR runners contesting the ball and there was far too little kick pressure on Campese and Kelly. They're both good enough without allowing them time to get the kick in.

Our kicking game was less pinpoint and never gave us much chance at getting the ball back.

I thought we played dumb football at times, pushing the pass and making unnecessary offloads in the wrong areas. It's good that we feel confident enough to chance our arm but some stuff was just plain daft. There were a few brainfarts from players who are sadly becoming a bit too well known for this.

On the good side we went forward up the middle all day. The pack was excellent and could've been even better with a fourth prop. My concerns about Walker in the centres were unfounded, he had a good game.

The ref made a few calls that I thought were debateable. The 2 on 1 steal on Addy was obviously ruled as a loose carry by him. That was a 50/50 call. But really, he shouldn't have needed to be fumbling to catch a risky offload from his teammate. We were a bit unlucky there but if we'd not tried the dodgy offload we'd not have been in that position.

The call where Baille was lying prone and play was allowed to continue looked inconsistent. I was unhappy about that but we must learn from it and not switch off. Play to the whistle!

The O'Brien "punch" looked to me less like a pre-meditated haymaker and more of a frustrated shove that went badly wrong. I'd like to see the replay. It was handbags after that. O'Brien himself says today it wasn't a proper punch.

The final score was a bit of a blowout and it wasn't that sort of game. I think with the likes of Mullaney, Purtell, Blythe, Williams and one of our props back we'll be a different proposition.

You know what the sun is shinning and I'm in a pretty good mood so i really can't be bothered to continue in a pointless argument we won at the end of the day so your right and I'm wrong enjoy the rest of your season and hopefully our paths won't have to cross again for a good few seasons

I doubt a different ref would have made enough difference but a few different players, on either side, might have done. If/ when we get Rovers in the middle eights then I would hope we have learned enough about their strengths, and our weaknesses in relation to that. Of particular note was their kicking game and how we didn't do enough to deal with it. It's not like it's a new revelation that the wind swirls around Odsal. Ideally shutting down the kicks , or attempting to and having the right defenders in place to deal with what gets through.......Purtell is usually fairly good at standing strong at it.......A bit more success in that part of the game makes an obvious improvement. I think the offensive side of kicking depends on who is in the squad but for me we need more capability.....as in a wider spread of individuals. It's stating the obvious and I presume it's frequently worked on.

Quite agree. While the punch from Sidlow was seen by most fans at the game, the 'punch' by Walker was actually a push in the face which was admitted by O'Brien in the Bradford paper today. He could have won an Oscar award in the way he threw himself on the floor

Did the fish head morons manage to get the bar closed at half time again or did they behave themselves yesterday?

Let's stay on topic please if possible.

No excuses for the lack of kick pressure.

But in the first half, HKR peppered our rt side defence with high kicks and they didn't get a lot of joy from it. Their catchers were under pressure and invariably we got the ball back in some form or another.

The second half, 2 things changed. HKR were kicking into the wind, so the ball held up more. But more importantly, our winger was injured and replaced at half time, leaving Walshaw (2nd row) & Henry as our centre/wing combo. And that didn't work with HKR scoring 3 tries from kicks down that side in the second half.

But they should have at least been under some kind of pressure.

As for striking - what was manifestly unfair was that both sides got the same penalty. I thought red for Walker & yellow for Sidlow, or yellow for Walker & a warning for Sidlow would have been fair. But ultimately, I'll respect the disciplinary verdict. If they hit Walker with a 1 match ban, then he should have had a red card in game.

I don't think the fact a 'chippy' little sod like Adam O'B, came out, like an old boxer, who blood streaming from every orifice says, "He never caught me with a proper punch ref", changes anything; he knocked O'Brien off his feet, and personally, [iI expect[/i our 'big lads' to protect our 'little lads' when their 'big lads' start trying to show how tough they are by knocking them about.

We did lose it on the kicks though. Maybe we don't protect our catcher well because we don't expect them to try and catch it? Far too often we allow the ball to bounce. You just can't do that at any level and it's been a feature of our season to me. The one on the kick off was the worst of all though.

Jimmy is going to have a selection headache once all our wingers are fit, because both Uaisele and Ulugia did really well yesterday I thought. Hopefully Ulugia's injury isn't too bad because Rovers struggled to put him down in the first half.

He will have selection headaches all over when you look at calibre of forwards not making cut. He can handle it. I wonder how much of his preferred starting line up is clear to him.....or is there no such thing. Looking forward to seeing Davies again as he looked like he could do some damage.

A fully fit Bradford squad will give any coach selection headaches and I think the players know this. Perfect example would be Walker who yesterday probably had one of his best games ever in a Bradford shirt and I'd say that is at least partly down to the fact that there's very few players in the squad who are guaranteed a spot. So far I think there's only Gaskell, O'Brien, Sidlow, Clough and Pitts who you'd imagine would get picked without thinking. The rest of the team is very much up for grabs

Wheres mullally?