Govin is not good enough and always injured,Penkys no 6 i think we can all see that,his kicking game is shocjing,his ball distribution is awful and wayward most of the time and he as a tendency to play his own game instead of sticking to the game plan.Beswick is a great distributor but hes being relied on to much for his defence.We need an old headed player with vast experience who can guide us around the park.Lokk at the difference Jamie Rooney has made at Barrow,he steady,s them down with his vision and kicking skills and he constantly puts the opposition on the back foot.

well we can't get one, so get behind govin as he is the best for the job at the club.

Can Gleeson play 6?

Better at 9, i think my order of preference would be:

Govin
Beswick
Anthony Bowman
Gleeson
Penky

Govin is good enough you tell he is class when he is on the pitch just very unlucky with injuries he will get better with match fitness aswell

I think we should have brought Bowman on this year, hes looked quality when given the chance, id still be tempted to give him a go now, he would add something in attack other than our usual stuff.
I suppose we have to trust the management that hes not mentally and physically ready, but i think his development could have been speeded up with some bravery from selectors.

Should of loaned him out or let him play at siddal he's just wasted a year not doing anything

you can have Watson

Govin is a class player - no doubt. However, he seems to be one of these players who get injured a lot. It's not just at 'Fax that he has been unlucky - he had knee and shoulder reconstructions at Leigh, too. I don't know why, but some players just seem to have more than their fair share of injuries.

Anyway, all the best to him for an injury-free remainder of his career!

Heremia?

Every one scores against Rooney when he is in the defensive line. Watch the videos. He's not that good, Or Wakey would have kept him.

Not that good?????? Are you serious????
I'd have him back tomorrow!
He's currently the best 7 in the league by "a country mile"!!!!!
Great kicking game, great hands (either way), cracking organiser, reads a game well and is very elusive. Watch your vids again and see how much defensive organisation he does - all the time!!

There isn't a better 7 in the league Cassandra!

Saying he's cr@p cos wakey got rid is daft. He's playing in the championship now and is like saying Gleeson or Dom Maloney are cr@p as their teams got rid - which is also tripe!!!

Where have I said he was crap. The thread is about a 6 not a 7 . Watch the videos , when he's defending his try line he is CRAP!!!!

Yep, he needs to be playing, learning his trade

oh I don't know where I got the idea - ok you didn't use the word cr@p - you said he's not that good!!

So you'd agree then, Maloney, Gleeson et al aren't very good either??? = daft comment!

I disagree entirely with your assessment of his defensive abilities - and I've seen him play many many times!