I think Sky should adopt the same format were you can hear what the video ref is saying and his reasoning behind his decision.

Seconded

It's not going to stop them making errors just because you can hear them though.

Could tell if he was ed though!

I never said vexed

I can think of 1 that would not have been allowed.

Ganson
"Just run that one through in slow motion"

Ganson
"Can you show it again from another angle"

Ganson
"The man I am tracking does not have the ball and has not put it down over the line"

Ganson
"It's a try"

Maybe you are right.

At least we could hear their thoughts. right or wrong
Can only be a positive

You think those idiots will shut up for us to hear the VR? Ha ha.

Its a usual stupid comment from Hemmings "that people think we are the video ref" This would stop the idiot from making the inane remark anymore. I like the BBC version and if everybody can hear the video ref making a right pigs ear of this decision it might make them think again.........or is that utopia !!!!!!

The VR needs to be either at EVERY game or no games at all. It is however here to stay so there needs to be transparency.

For that to happen we need to be able to see and hear what they are doing.

There also needs to be at least two independent persons with the ref but the ref has ultimate decision making control.

When a decision is made there must be a reason given and that reason must be shown to the supporters. So if he has tracked a certain player or a player is offside...etc then this MUST be pointed out on the screen.

Sky have access to such amazing technology and use it for their highlights shows in all other sports. This kind of equipment can be used for the VR decisions so that they are able to show supporters what they are looking at.

I also believe that teams should be given 4 video ref referrals per game. If you use them then that is it everything else is down to the officials on the pitch.

The advantage to the attacking team should be scrapped. As in Australia now, the ref makes his decision, it then goes to the VR and if he can't decide then it goes back to the original decision.

Whether or not we can hear the current system is irrelevant unless we can see what is going on too and the whole thing is changed to be a much fairer system.