The nominees are sam tomkins,chase and roby.
For me only one winner sam tomkins,one of a kind, great ability can't stand how he is,but wish he played for hullkr.!

Id go for roby

Roby for me, but I reckon it will go to Tomkins.

Can't understand why Monaghan isn't included. The Super League season still hasn't finished and if Monaghan inspires Warrington to GF winners rings and runs rings round Tomkins surely this isn't a fair award. Yeah Wigan won the challenge cup but the man of steel is surely for displays in SL matches.

Great player that chase is,I would probably picked monaghan ahead of chase for the three.!

For me chase hasn't done enough to earn a spot grt player I wud ave prob gone for Graham

its not a popularity contest,Tomkins by a mile

Personally don't get all the hype around Chase. Has some good games but is appalling in others and plays to his own game plan often to the detrement of the team. Hasn't done enough this year to even get a nomination IMO.

Out of the 3 I'd have to go with Tomkins although his form has dipped towards the end of the season. I thought Monaghan would have had a shout at it personally.

Tomkins for me, but I agree that Monaghan should have been in ahead of Chase.

Tomkins will win it I'm pretty sure of that but I dont get why Monaghan has been overlooked. he has been superb at leading Wire round all season

I wonder why Scott Dureau or Steve Menzies from the dragons are not there? they have been outstanding this year & made an average side into a good side.

Is it the players that choose from the start? Or do they choose after it gets whittled down to 3? Or have I got it completely wrong & it's naff all to do with the other players?

if it is the players who decides Tomkins attitude is not liked by lots of players