I agree with your sentiments regarding those two, they just don't cut the mustard as far as I can see.
I just don't understand what the fascination with Marsh is, perhaps the coaches can see some huge potential there but it must be well hidden because I cant see it and I've see enough good players in the professional and amateur ranks in my time to realise a potential good one when I see one.
Plus, to play him today in such an important game when he hasn't had any game time all season was madness in my opinion. Marsh and Minns, though the latter was obviously injured, were clearly at fault on that left hand side when Halifax were running in the tries down that flank.

Jewitt and Scruton are both good forwards

Thought minns was awful before his injury

Hy Marwan. I suspect you will be back in middle8s next year if format stays the same.Dont think any Salford fan can with any credibility call other clubs tinpot or e house. Thanks for popping by,don't hurry back

Wow, bit unfair on him considering he got injured inside the first 2 minutes.

apart from a rich piece of kak your club has got absolutely nothing going for it,no youth or fans, time will tell on you 3rs

To be fair he was injured very early on so didn't really have time to get going, but you could see he was struggling after that knock so I don't know why they left him on so long. Carny was left looking at the inside defenders on a few occasions, wondering what they were doing, it appeared that communication between Marsh and Minns was non existent at times.

Couple of pints after game and looking back,we won which was all that mattered.Leigh away next up was always going to be tough but even if we lose we are still where we probably thought we would be. Next week we just need to see improvement and fitness back into new/returning players,if we win by some miracle so be it.Widnes and Catalan home games particularly Widnes will be the key.

Blah blah fans, youth yawwwwn. Has Hudgell still yet to do his smoking out? HAHAHAHAHAHAHA Can imagine all your tired six fingers furiously typing away celebrating your victory against a bunch of mechanics and plumbers. Comedy gold at Craven Park.

Why oh why do the club, coach and players like the hard way?! Ffs do us fans go through enough as it is!

Salford - gutter club with gutter fans.

Last response from me to your buffoonery. Just enjoy your decent season

Oh the irony a Salford sorry Manchester Red Devil fan from next season calling us tinpot 7,700 there today about the same number that your 4 home games will bring especially as you banning about 20 a game

How many more times..Marsh in the halves..NO NO NO NO NO!! it has never worked, he offers next to nothing. However, Carney...is a beast, fantastic. Never thought I would say it but we miss Abdull..Atkin IS a half back, could he be worse than what was out there today, I doubt it, but what other options apart from Blair do we have at the moment, but I don't really want him in the halves either. Its a big concern, lets just hope we can solve it or we could get mullerd by the Super League teams.

Well, that felt more like a loss.

With the drive home to reflect and promote more rational thought.

What went on with Minns is anyone's guess, but I also think the player has a responsibility to put his hand up and admit he's become a liability.

Credit to 'Fax, they played well. Another quality performance from The Drighlington Dynamo (who took me calling him a fat #*@%) in the spirit intended. They made very few mistakes and carried out an effective straight forward game plan.
Dear Dr
Lunt was superb in that last half hour, without him, we don't win that game, but how long he can go on playing eighty minutes at hooker, scrum half and stand off is a concern.

That bench today made no sense, Ellis really is just not good enough but I saw nothing in Atkin at Swinton to excite and nothing so far here to understand us signing him, never mind paying a fee. Early days though.