Hope you've got space at HKR for Eden's ego...the lad is a world beater in his head and an egg beater on the park.

Forget the sour grapes and negativity, if this is true (and I and many others hope it isn't) then you will have a fantastic English talent on his way.

He is nowhere near 3rd best fullback at Giants and to have him behind Grix a man who couldn't catch or tackle last season is laughable.

Eden makes errors, drops the odd high ball, so does Tomkins and Billy Slater!!! Hardaker at Leeds was another who looked lost and next minute he is a very good fullback who has represented his country, Eden has the potential to be a lot better.

I could also see him develop into a Danny McGuire type stand off (without the sulking hopefully) he has pace to burn and can spot a gap, to sum up if its true the Giants have yet again shot themselves in the foot and you will have another good player with potential to become great.

Ot but Walker is gonna make a good one too and could emulate what Chris Hill as done.

Giraffe?!



brough and robinson combo

lunt and faiumu hooking combo

Ah, yes. Forgot about Robinson, I was thinking that Grix might play there again. I can see the reasoning, with those four and Cudgoe also able to play fullback if required then I can see how his lack of versatility might make Eden surplus to requirements.

He has agreed terms he will be with HKR next year.

Not sure he will reach those hights but totally agree we should not be letting him go and he has shown enough in his fairly few SL apperances that he is the sort of guy you want to be looking to sign rather than sell and unless there is another signing coming in to replace him do not see it as good business at all.


Perhaps there is an attitude or personality issue with Anderson but on the face of it a good move for KR and a bad one for Giants I would say.

Two good signings in a row now, and 4 good signings out of 6 in my opinion. I'd much rather have Eden than McDonnell. Both clubs should do better than last season.

I think we have have signed 8 raggytash

If Eden can reduce his number of mistakes in a game he has the potential to be a very close 2nd to Tomkins in England full backs. Rumour has it his attitude needs bringing down a peg or two which gets other players backs up but if there's someone at the club to keep him in line he'll do fine. Walker played in the early part of the season and did ok but he really needs to work on his leg speed if he's going to be a SL regular. Hope both guys do well for you except against us.

Best signing so far if true. Fingers crossed.

If that's true, you'll struggle. Massively.

Why do you think he's the third choice fullback?

I'll give you a little tip.

Constantly rubbishing everything about Rovers with absolutely no attempt at objectivity leads to everyone instantly dismissing all of your opinions.

In essence, what you're doing is a complete waste of time, but if that's how you get your kicks you crack on.

Great signing if you pull this one off , only seen him a couple of times tbh (like most non giants fans) but what ive seen he looks like he has got massive potential. Im suprised nathan brown hasnt come in for him

Look just cos uve signed liz macdonald on ridiculous money don't come sulking on here

LOL

No way!

Travis Burns and Evarn Tuimavave are top drawer.

47 errors a year and a cocky attitude maybe?



Could be great. Could be Kevin Penny.

I'd agree with travis burns phwooaar the pecs on him

Good signing for KR imho, liked the look of him last year for what i saw

How much is shannon on then ? #intheknow

I'm one of the few Rovers fans who think McDonnell is a very good attacking full-back and I was originally disappointed he didn't stay with us but I'm glad now that we've signed Eden.

Although he's not the finished article yet, he's an excellent signing IMO.

He's on a lorra lorra money he is

Haha dont come cheap these exiles players

What biased cack you talk. My personal opinion is that the signings you have made are pretty dire in contrast to the ones you've sold. Eden is nowhere near McDonnell's quality. The fact you didn't see the best of him is down to your coaching team. Much the same as Watts. He's a far better player under a decent coach and setup. Taylor will also be the same.

Its called a contrary opinion. If you don't like 'em, you really need to bury your head, ostrich-boy.