'Almighty God' knew, Paul McShane will no doubt be a fantastic short term signing for Hull FC providing your forwards grow a set and give him the opportunity to put the team on the front foot.

One bad game, Well that's it then throw him to the scrap heap he's obvioulsy never going to make it if he's had a bad game in his career.

Anyone who goes to watch the u20's think any of them could make the step up ?

That kid Moa looks a decent prospect.

if we dont look at mcshane, huddersfield have robinson, lunt and drew (almost fit again) contesting the hooking position, would it be worth making a load move for any of these?

No chance in my opinion of the getting the first two. Think Drew would count on the quota too, unless he's good European heritage. McShane looks the only one available unless Wigan wanted to ship McIlorum out with them having Riddell and Deacon/Leuluai but then again Wigan would probably want the wages paying in full and it's a long journey over from Wigan.

so much for gratitude eh?
you lose your no:9 and are thus rendered even more useless than the week previous!
we gratuitously loan you one of our best academy prospects to help you out in your hour of need
and we get comments like these?




i just hope that macca will be in safe hands whilst he's there,maybe the tongan maffia will take him under their wing

I am gratful by the way for you letting us loan him, but I can understand fans wanting a better player like Robinson or Lunt.

At least he won't have bailey pestering him constantly to pick the soap up in the showers

well thats a total different matter all together then
but if you want them then you'll have to manage your salary cap better to get those players!
the words"all eggs in one basket" spring to mind

Lucky your sinfield egg wasn't out for that long then

McShane likely to be at Brantingham tomorrow.

www.sporthull.co.uk/hullfc/news/ ... ticle.html?

www.sporthull.co.uk/hullfc/news/ ... ticle.html?

Officially announced: www.hullfc.com/hullfc/contents/?p=5917

Officially announced: www.hullfc.com/hullfc/contents/?p=5917

That says a lot in itself

For all good this guy may be wasn't the idea of no relegation to promote your own young players, we have a hooker we have a scrum half lets give our own kids a go how much worse can we play look at HOUGHTON BRISCOE YEAMAN HORNE give our kids a chance

It's ok giving youngsters a chance when they're 19/20, 16-18 is a different matter.

Exactly. Our kids are nowhere near ready, most of them anyway.

Or we could have got Tommy Lee back

graeme horne??

promising start, thought we left it a bit late to bring him on

couple of good runs and some good tackles and a decent kick

Thought he would of got more than 20 minutes but did well anyway except for the forward pass, but overall his distribution was fast and accurate. Solid I'd say, as many were tonight.

Thought he did well when he came on.

He did very well tonight and he is large and chunky as well as being quick on his feet. He could prove to be a good signing if even for a short time, Leeds will get a player back better then the one they sent I reckon.

How dare he come to this club, throw crisp, acuurate passes 20 yards out wide from dummy half and expect to get away with it. Send him packing!

Why isn't Agar coaching him ?