If you base it on that it's most likely going to be the same players every week unless they have a shocker, and thereby a redundant process.

I've always rated him as a backrower, but yesterday was the first time I've truly rated his performance at prop. Like Staffs I was a bit unsure about him being picked, but he fully justified it.

Fair enough best to leave it as it is. That said Whiting's value yesterday was clearly his versatility when on another day if he plays in the back row then that versatility is less valuable.

Whiting did a good job in difficult circumstances but he did make some errors that could have been very costly. His knock on from a bread and butter pass was very unlike Whiting and very nearly led to a try and he was out of position for the Waterhouse try (still not convinced he grounded that actually). All in all he did ok filling in at fullback.

Pretty much how I saw it.

Not sure he was out of position for the Waterhouse try, just lacked the pace to get there.

I don't think he got it down either!

Poor game again tonight

Only played in 4 different positions

I'm a big fan.

Whiting decent again tonight.

can see the influence of Ellis on his running and defence, put a good shift in tonight

I'm running out of superlatives for Richard Whiting. You just get great every week. I also thought Gareth Ellis had a tremendous game. Defended exceptionally and really attacked the line with the ball.

Whiting = Superman

Simples