That is funny!

So what am I wrong about, genius?

He certainly is pure class and will be a huge star of the future. Ive also said before that Welham has the ability to go far, he just isnt the natural player that Hall is imo.

Same could be said for Cooke

Dobson will be found out this year as been nothing more than average.

Like he did in his other spells in SL for catalan and Wigan?

Hall is not 'pure class', Inglis is 'pure class' not Hall.

Newton and Galea made the dream team after a good first half of the season, both were very poor for the 2nd half of the season. Fitz wasnt even here but Galea and Newton arent fit to lace his boots. Manu was off form for me last year and still won our POTY. He is head and shoulders above both Newton and Galea when on form, hense me selecting him.

Murrell has developed in SL far more than i would have imagined however if it wasnt for injuries Washy could have made the current England squad and will do in the future. Murrell will always remain steady.

He was behind good packs at both those clubs and was behind a pack for Rovers that were incredibly lucky that they had very few injuries and all of the competition seemed to be under performing.

Welham and Hall.....Hall is sheer class and a damn sight more skillful and a better strike player....how many tries did Welham get in a "superior" team to Hall in a "inferior" team...Hall can score tries out of nothing....i havent seen Welham do this or have the ability to do it.

I would have Manu in the backrow with Newton and Galea at 13...that way you have a bruiser in Newton....a tackle buster in Manu and a creative 13 in Galea.

As for Dobson and Long.....lets see what Dobson wins in his career before you dismiss long.

Hows for for a reasonable debate.............and my idiot is still waiting for your brain.

As was Cooke! Thats my point. Horne is still a far better 6 than Cooke ever will be. Remind me which one has played for GB?

Fair point. But if Hall goes down the class scale on that basis Welham will drop off the bottom.

You would have Fitz in the back row?

On the wing or in his favoured position?

Cooke was no way worse than Horne last season!