I thought Sneyd showed it in some parts and his kicking game was good. Pryce only played for 5 minutes and got us back in the game. Not sure what the answer is, as if we move Carlos who plays centre? Would have to be Abdul.

Sorry but with the squad we have which is the best by far in 10 years at least with proper headline names we should be doing far better than 5th/6th.
5th IS failure, not getting to a final this year IS a failure. The yardstick to define failure has already being set at the end of 2013.
Whilst it's still early doors not being able to close out games we've had ample chances to win due to dumb rugby and same old mistakes is unacceptable.

This is the question.

Think Sneyd was given MOM

Which player gave away the penalty for the off the ball challenge at the end when Shaul caught the ball?

Well what can I say? I thought it was pretty much the same blueprint as cas game. Rubbish in first half with too many penalties, a period of about 15 minutes where we dominated and got into the lead and then threw it away late on with a silly penalty. Sums it up.

Ridiculous comment. The Challenge Cup is a random draw. If we draw Wigan or Leeds away and lose that is not a failure.

No idea, one of a few questionable decisions from thaler

1st minute forward pass, where? Wigan score, tautai nit even sent to the bin but placed on report so no doubt will miss the next game, sargison loses the ball and looks up at thaler all dough eyes and gets the penalty

Whilst not the reason we lost he played a big part in some questionable decisions against us


Time and time we over play and panic near the opposition line then let in a soft try likevtheir second and third tries

I'm really starting to think refs manufacture close games purposely, like it makes it entertaining or something. Saying tha,t our goal line defence is shocking. All we do is panic.

Think that was Sneyd but from where I was sat didn't look like he touched anyone.

Certainly not as clear as Gale running into Shaul last week from the kick off which didn't get punished.

You got some luck off the officials as well though.

If we did its the only thing thaler gave us, still no excuse for failing to act on tautai

It's not a knee jerk reaction but I just don't think they are good enough. Pryce is way passed his best and seems to go missing. Sneyd is capable of good things but at times his decision making is like his defence terrible. Both of them need to take the line on more to keep the opposition guessing. Really fecked off by that. Wigan were poor but know how to win close games. I, like probably most of the fans knew that even when we took the lead late on we would panic and lose.

i'm not even sure tautai was placed on report, i think he was just warned with penalty sufficient. i've always been against lifting in the tackle, its dangerous. we have already had a serious case in the NRL, and its only a matter of time before a player over here suffers a serious injury. time to start red carding such offences

Thaler bottled it. Sin binning should have been the minimum