Not one of ours, but nevertheless he's surely someone who every fan must admire.

Manu would have got torn apart by the threepenny stand on his return. However, time moves on and maybe Menzies deserves a clap after the game ..

Menzies never played for us.

Menzies is a legend. He's played RL at top level on two continents for the last 90 years (or so ).

In the 3d days, it was a lot more common for players to stay at one club for a long time, so reactions to returning players were stronger.

But yeah, apart from that, your reasoning is totally sound.

That really bugged me last Friday night. Why were some of our fans chanting 'Manu' as the players ran out? He doesn't play for us any more and it doesn't send a great message to our current playing roster.

As far as I'm concerned, they can do anything they want with Steve Menzies AFTER the game. We need to be fully focused on beating the Cats.

I can only disagree with this suggestion. Whilst I admire Menzies as a player this is also a professional game meaning I want Hull FC to win tonight and in the Grand Final!

Would we be so generous in applauding Michael Dobson for his services to Hull KR if we'd been playing them tonight? I think not!