Agree about Tanginoa but with Arona now back and Fifita due back I’m sure he’ll return to the second row!

On Ashurst...he was defending a Hull right edge attack of Fonua, Griffin and M’au...probably as formidable a right edge as there is and he made 37 tackles and missed a few...surely we can let that off against such quality opposition? On the try scoring front we came out on top that side anyway!

And on team selection...we came within a whisker of beating one of the best teams in the comp still with a few key players missing...Koppy might just be one of those who struggles these days with short turnarounds being a big lad and 33 years old...

I thought Josh Wood was poor against Salford.

defense for the hull tries was horrible

Anyone with half a brain cell knows why Tanginoa has been used as a battering ram at prop since week 1 and dropping Ashurst is probably the dumbest comment I’ve read on here for a while.

For me Tupou is wasted on the wing, leave him and Johnstone together it’s a lethal combination. Atkins played well but Tupou can create more space for our wonder kid on the wing..

Walker, created a great try for Atkins with a wonderful pass but for me was very ordinary. Passing too early and not drawing defenders in. I know it’s early days but I’m not convinced.

Agree re tanginoa and ashurst, don't agree about the centres though. Atkins been great there for me, TJ has scored 4 in his last 3, tupou scored off an outrageous lyne pass.

Walkers been ok,shown flashes of quality but not really settled yet. Plenty of potential but when Rockies back he's competing with him and Max and atm you have to fancy the other 2

Which game this season was described as Tanginoa most productive, Salford away when he was playing in the second row rather than prop.

Agree with all that mate....I get the feeling that Walker hasn't fully settled in yet as he seems a bit apprehensive at times, but that off-load to Atkins was sublime, so there is definitely more to come from him.

That’s harsh on Crowther. He’s not a hooker, but I thought he was outstanding when he came back on at loose. I always expect him to be the one dropped when the big names come back, but there can’t be many players who get through the work he does. Keeps improving every year for me.

He was 2nd row at Salford, half a brain boy

It's easy to see why your so popular on here