Quote: Willzay "Yes because Washbrook at 9 was a huge success wasn't it? Stifled our attack yet made no difference to the defence either.I don't know why you obsess about size tbh, yiu could be the biggest bloke on the pitch but if you have the heart of a pea...
More of 9 than Godinet? Ha! Godinet when given time at dummy half has proven to be successful e.g against Wigan few weeks ago.
As for his defensive qualities? well I'm sure time and time again Carter has said he doesn't know much about rugby and if he thinks Howarth brings defensive qualities then God help us.'"
Sorry but Godinet is not a 9, he's isn't strong enough defensively and offers very slow distribution from the PTB. He's an old fashioned HB IMHO and would absolutely rip it up in the Championship. I know you think he is better than Mc Shane but he isn't, not even in the same class. Jeez even NGBC can see that.
When Godinet comes on he makes a difference but it's all one man stuff, OK I suppose but it won't win you many games.
