some of you guys are just a joke. the boys have played 4 competitive games and been conpetitive. they will only get better. i fear some onhere will never get better.

are you talking about poster or players

Just moaning for the sake of it.

I've seen 3 games thus year, and then watched 2 again on tv.
No one is not giving effort. Some have started better than others.
I'm happy with how we are going. It will take time but its coming.

And as for Southern specifically. He us outstanding. You need to go watch the game again.

Didn't say they weren't.

As stated in my post, i wasn't sure if i hadn't been watching him close enough, or whether being played out of position was also not helping his cause.

FFS, it's an opinion, and it makes you chuckle when some of the most opinionated people on the forum dislike other's having one.

Yep, let us know when you post something worth discussing

i will ignore those that seemingly think that having a discussion about this topic should be off limits. it's noticable that the names in this thread are the ones that are in generally not in the thread about the most impressive signings, so regardless of those that don't want to discuss this topic they have in their own way contributed elsewhere by default.

i put mellars. i understand he's one of the biggest earners in the squad, and he certainly shone with the crusaders. so i was expecting him to be more of a standout as we formed as a team, although it looks like we have to wait until we have formed as a unit for him to stand out. pretty simple really, on his money and with his track record he should look like a senior player, and at the moment he doesn't.

if the players read this then i'm okay with that. there are no posters slagging people off.

I really cant see the point some of you are making about Mellars ? Having watched every game we have had this season i can honestly say that there is nothing that dissapoints me about the performances he puts in. or am i just been simple, Can someone please explain?

i think i just expected him to be a stand out, to command his side of the field with real authority; the same way aiton does up the middle.

On a positive note, Got to say im really impressed with Aitons workload especially in defense. Hes made 185 Tackles in 4 games and that just puts him under James Roby ( Only Just) and we have a game in hand ! He looks the real deal

Chill man! Wasn't an attack on you, just my point of view.
Some have expressed that opinion. I'm saying I don't agree.

For God's sake, we've only played 4 matches!!!

No need to chill, just sick of people trying to force opinions down others neck's, then getting on their high horse's when someone else expresses one of their's.

so what? those that have contributed to the thread, as opposed to those that have tried to de-rail it are entitled to their opinions. there has been no unfair comments about players and their ability. if it's right to have a discussion about who's doing well, then it's equally valid to have a debate about who has been most dissapointing this season SO FAR.

Fat Faced 'Fan' has dissappointed me the most this season. Looks pretty negative and lazy