Because he's not as talented as his brother, no wrong he is probably as talented but lacks the drive. SL is far less streesed than the NRL and I don't think David was suited to it, his brother struggles. However in the more relaxed SL at a small club where he is the biggest fish by some way it does suit him.

I don't think we should get carried away, Dave just fits at Trinity in a way he probably wouldn't eleswhere, especially the NRL.

I don't follow NRL so I had never heard of him or his brother. I remember one poster saying he was gash and not even reserve grade, well he hasn't turned out that bad at all.

I also remember his first year and although a good player he had a lot of daft things in his game. Remember away at warrington when he made a ash of playing the ball with seconds to go and it costing us the game. I think the guy has really settled in and now this seems to be his best season ever. I do think he has huge natural talent but I am also in that school which believe the club and its environment is also greatly responsible the 'The Big Bopper' to blossom into a terrific prop.

They didn't miss him.
He was at Cronulla and looking good but he and his brother lacked focus when they were together. Andrew is quite outspoken.
They decided he wasn't worth the trouble as they had other options.

Seperating has done them both good.
I'm sure he could get a gig in NRL but he'd have to train harder and fit a more rigid game plan.
We suit his style better and hopefully he sees that too.

I think that he's still prone to the occasional error and has been pinged for issues around the ptb.
However, what we have seen since the Warrington game that you mention is the destructive go forward and some try's and his infectious grin, which makes the bloke an absolute joy to watch.
I'm happy to forgive a few errors and penalties conceded as the "plus" column is massive and who knew about the audacious side step in his locker, brilliant

I know it's tongue in cheek but the eats pies score tries mantra probably wouldn't be quite as well accepted in the NRL. He clearly is enjoying himself, and there is a lot to be said about that. He has the talent to be in the NRL, but perhaps he would be miserable in a robotic structure and wouldn't quite be as effective.

I remember an interview a few seasons back where one of them was talking about a mental issue he had, I cannot remember if it was Andrew or David, but it was very emotional even to the point where one of the twins was too upset and walked out of the room, like I’ve said very emotional interview.

It’s Andrew who suffers from depression as well as being quite intense - very outspoken in support of a friend who was a one punch killer, can’t recall his name. It got Andrew in a lot of bother and lost him a place in the Australian team. It was a big deal a few years back.

In the interview Andrew expressed suicidal thoughts which proved to much for David and he walked out of the interview. Twins may look the same but they don’t all think the same. I know this because oddly I was friend with three sets of twins during my youth though not all at once. Dave is clearly more laid back and up for a laugh - this is a strength and a weakness. Ditto Andrew but the other way around.

Bit like the Fox brothers, Neil well balanced and personable, Don introverted and intense, Peter well he was just a one off and to me tats what Dave is, just a force of nature.



Bit long winded but o had some time on my hands

That sounds very familiar BLM

Personally I think Dave getting out of the lime light of the NRL and being in the right environment here has helped him thrive

It's being such a pleasure to see him reach his potential
I used to love watching Dave Solamona the guy was pure magic, Dave is a different type of player with a different skill set but still has that same magic when he get the ball

The bonus being how much he loves us fans and how much we love him back

I think he's become the heart beat of our team if such a thing is possible

Solomona was the better player and a true game breaker and the best player I’ve seen in a Trinity shirt. However I now like Dave even more, not just because of what he does but the way the whole team plays when he’s on. He brings out the best in his fellow players and when he’s on we look a top team and that makes him worth his considerable weight in gold.

Not a bad post for a thicky

HE isn't as skilled as his brother - NOR as fit (not that any of them are) but Andrew can go longer mins in the NRL.

trust me those silly pens and mistakes and costing us game is still there it will happen again this year - but for now we will take him winning us games- that's why he suits a msmall club like us and not NRL or a bigger club - its rocks and diamonds - but so far this year it is DIAMAONDS!!!

ITS Andrew