What a bloody shambles, how the hell is our squad expected to compete with Leigh , Bradford and Halifax in the Middle 8. We know that we have no chance against the SL teams. Think Leigh and Bradford will stuff us and we may run Fax close.

it is certainly a good one for the doom laden moaners, that's for sure.

I think we (Cas) have got the better end of the deal here and can totally understand the sentiments already mentioned regarding the relationship between our two clubs. I rate McShane and think he'll go ok for us. I don't think he'll have to do as many minutes at Cas or have as much pressure on him to create/perform, but it might be next season before we really see any benefit as his fitness isn't where it needs to be.
What I will say about Moore is that I was really unhappy when we signed him, but have got to hold my hands up and say he's a better player than I gave him credit for and he'll definitely add some steel to your defence. Barring the odd brain fart I think you'll be pleasantly surprised with him.

why are cas laughing at us ,hes just an average hooker,scott moore is just what we need for the middle 8.much tougher and loads of experience far better tackler than p mcshane imo.

M carter been asked on twitter if anymore players coming in and his reply "1 but its a longshot"

Our Cas reject quota must be full.

Whilst they can never tell the whole story thats not what the stats say....

McShane
22 games
593 tackles (ave. 27 per game)
36 misses (ave 1.64)

Moore
14 games
333 tackles (ave 23.8 )
32 misses (ave. 2.3)

Given that McShane has been playing in a badly beaten side all season and Moore hasn't then those stats look even better for him. He is better in every other statistical area as well. He was our only ever present this year so he has certainly showed some toughness there as well.

As for experience, yes Moore has played about 40 games more than Mcshane, then again we are his 10th club change and 7th different club by the age of 27. Tells you something.

if a teams getting beat every week the coach has got to do something,getting rid of the weak links, thats what bs is doing,or do you want nothing to change and just carry on,dont underestimate bs or mc.

Not a big fan of either and if we have to loose McShane for something/one better long term then so be it.

We don't appear to be getting anything of quality out of all these wakey - cas deals do we?????

Don't have a problem with this. Mc shanes no interest and a new face with a better attitude will do for me. Mc shane was over rated.

What worries me is that we havent had a settled team since smith took charge and now were going into the middle 8 with yet more squad changes. Wete hardly going to be a cohesive unit as opposedto other teams who have a relatively settled 17

Come on wake up and smell the coffee we have no intentions of being here once the season is over. We are planning to clear the decks making it easier to finalise everything with the minimum inconvenience. We are now working on ensuring our relegation by bringing in players on short term contracts who are either already signed for next season with other clubs or are so poor no one else would want them.
I know you need your pacifiers to get through all this negativity. I see the usual he was not that good anyway, we are bringing in better all praise M Carter he saved us but unfortunately he is now ruling over our imminent demise. When we go we can at least say we went with a clean slate and a chairman loved by all others in the game.
Yes I am annoyed more at the idiots on here with rose titled spectacles who will not face what the rest of us can see. I expect you will be standing outside the gates of Belle Vue next year whist fully remembering the halcyon days.

if I was you I'd ask the mrs to move all sharp knives away from the draw and stick corks on the forks

So why are you still here then Scarlet? Doesn't seem worth watching and certainly not posting about the terrible state we are in.
You should cut your loses and do something else that you enjoy.

My glasses aren't tinted. I know what state we are in.....but I'm supporting anyway.

I am sure Scarlet knows what state we are in and he is still supporting the club just like you. I am also sure
the reason he is so negative is because he loves the club and hates to see it dying.