Really hard one to call this, both arguments are strong, it’s our aweful kicking game since Finn ran out of steam V’s brough as a person, his ability is not in question, I have still seen him kick teams to death to get shuddes over the line. After another good season with a pretty non exsistent kicking game is exactly where we will be next year 5 again ,our props by end of this season were pretty battered bruised from giving their all, no pressure being realeased by a skilled boot of individual that can spare the team a bit of gas to get over the line and nick those tight games that would place us in the mix for real shot at top 4, this may read as a cop out post , but I would back club signing him, but on flip side back why we didn’t, brave decision which ever way

I've heard this as well.

Broughy coming to Wakey and Grix going back to Shudds. Apparently as well as playing there will be coaching role for Grixy as well.

I like the Grix to Shudds part but Broughy coming here is bad news IMHO. I really can't see MC or CC wanting to ruin 3 years hard work a stunt like this might result in. Has the potential to be MC's worst ever move.

Great signing for a couple of years. Still looked dangerous last year definitely improves us and hopefully take Hampshire under his wing. A new FB now and I'm happy. Top business

I'll ask them to get it back in for especially you, do you also want the football table too

IF Brough comes back to Wakefield, Hampshire will be your new full back.

I sincerely hope this isn't true - he's done, and is entirely the wrong fit for the culture that CC has created around our squad.

And for anyone who looks to Broughy to take a young player under his wing - you obviously didn't watch the last time he was with us; he did quite the opposite.

Backward step - I wouldn't be in favour.

I hope not.

Although I think CC recruitment has been very good, this one really worries me. I hope, if he does come back, he cuts out all the snarling at team mates and refs.

Remember him throwing a pass a yard in front of Dale Morton then bollocking the lad for not taking it!

Never forgotten that - Morton had a torrid season playing with the misters in a beaten side - got smashed to bits every week - but always gave it a go; the spray that Broughy gave him for not taking that wild pass was shameful.

He can't and if people on here think this bloke has anything to offer I despair. It's taken years to create an ethos that a player like this could destroy in weeks.

This I'm afraid if it happens will be CC Julian O'neil signing and that would be sad because I thought he was better than that and still hope he is.

I've got a very uneasy feeling about this possible signing.

If true this seems to me as a direct replacement for Liam Finn - an older head to control the game when needed, albeit IMO Brough has a greater upside than Liam.