Quote: roverman "why are cas laughing at us ,hes just an average hooker,scott moore is just what we need for the middle 8.much tougher and loads of experience far better tackler than p mcshane imo.'"
Whilst they can never tell the whole story thats not what the stats say....
McShane
22 games
593 tackles (ave. 27 per game)
36 misses (ave 1.64)
Moore
14 games
333 tackles (ave 23.8 )
32 misses (ave. 2.3)
Given that McShane has been playing in a badly beaten side all season and Moore hasn't then those stats look even better for him. He is better in every other statistical area as well. He was our only ever present this year so he has certainly showed some toughness there as well.
As for experience, yes Moore has played about 40 games more than Mcshane, then again we are his 10th club change and 7th different club by the age of 27. Tells you something.