One of the most overrated players to ever wear the Wakey shirt. Played ok one in six games for us (at best) then went missing. Fantastic business to get rid for the Money we got. I would have driven him to Salford myself.

There is a reason that he is getting slagged off by the Salford fans.......... He is a below average player

Tim Smith has some excellent qualities and to slag him off as rubbish is off the mark for me.
However, his defence wasn't one of his qualities and he would be totally the wrong player in our team at the moment!
In a good team with good defenders round him he would still probably shine. I seem to remember him being applauded by many on here in the 7 match run of wins!

It's OK looking at Sneyd with the hindsight of this season under Powell. He was dire last year. The only player I can recall who ever kicked out 4 times on the full in one game! (down at Belle Vue during last seasons drawn game).

Agree with this completely. He made DK look great at times last year.
Although he wouldnt have helped with our current defensive issues, the one key area i feel we have really missed him is his chat. Even when we/he werent playing well he was there organising everything, pushing and pulling forwards into position, telling them exactly what he wanted. This is something i think we have lacked in buckets this year, maybe through the fact we have new players to the club in the halves, maybe because the people that are there dont have that in there game??

I think leadership is seriously lacking at the mo. Even DK when there doesnt appear to be great talker. On the many times i have seen us behind our own sticks this year, the only people i see getting vocal are Mcshane and maybe Sammut on occasions. Outside of that there is nobody getting them together until Stu Dickens appears with the water. I personally think this is why we have resorted to Sykes back in the 6 jersey, to give us some sort of experienced guidance. Unfortunately, i think he has just gone round 1 too many times.

Smith defence was awful but his attack was very good and if we were playing Sammut at stand off and Godinet at scrum half then no i wouldn't want Smith back. But seeing as our best halfbacks are currently playing fullback and interchange hooker then yes i'd have him back to play alongside Sykes again as he is streets ahead of Siejka at this point in time in all facets of the game i'm afriad.