My impression of him is that he's a good enough
player but not ready physically for Super League.
Is that right?.

The Warrington right edge probably won't agree with you

Possibly fair comment, but for a 6th or 7th choice winger, he did a pretty good job, I'd say...

I actually said at work last Monday that if we can bulk up Forsyth and Marshall to the levels of Manfredi and Budgie we have got major selection problems. Forsyth is 6ft 5"... I am trying to think if we still have time to re-train him in another position and utilize him in that way. I am no way saying that Forsyth is anything like Greg Inglis but that guy is a similar height and could literally play every position on the pitch. Would it be worth trying to turn Forsyth into a back rower for a couple of years down the line when we inevitably lose Bateman. Very risky i know but i can't see how he will ever get a game here as a winger.

Well, he's actually a centre, mainly.

We are probably a centre short too to be honest, that would work if he has the handling skills

The off-load in the 1st halfWarrington game shows he has,

Did Ok but missed far too many tackles. Too early to judge.

All the noises from Wane have been that he wasn't massively impressed with him. Ultimately he did pretty well with the ball but he could and maybe should have stopped both of the Wire try's down his side.

Tom Davies looks like he might take his place this week. He sounds like another top young player. In the commentary on the reserve game at the weekend it was mentioned that Davies broke the superleague record held by James Roby in the pre season fitness tests so energy clearly won't be an issue.

I thought he did ok. It's worth bearing in mind he was picked out of position on his debut and has missed a year or 2 of development not touching the ball in union reserve grade.

There's potential but I think he showed he's not ready yet.