Strongest squad of the season so far and fully fit barring Fielden and O'Carroll. Wonder if he will start Goulding or Charnley? Also, who will he play Tommy at 9 with Finch and Deacon 6 and 7. The rest of the team picks itself. Tuson and Goulding/Charnley to miss out.

Tough decision for Madge. Goulding was weak against Catalans but is generally quite a solid performer in defence and offers a lot of hard work. Charnley is the flashy player who is a handful in attack but makes a few too many errors and is certain to be targeted. I think he'll stick with Charnley though as he had a very good game against Hull KR.

Isn't Deacon a doubt because his wife is due to give birth around the time of the game?

No mention of Amos Roberts in the squad, yet again.

Charnley for me over Goulding. I think he's a bigger strike threat.

agreed Bilko, I think Gleeson made Goulding life's far easier last year. we now need a winger that creates an attacking threat rather than waiting for others to do it for them

Selfish cow!

Personally would go with Goulding over Charnley, experience of the big games just gives him the nod for me.

Saints: Paul Wellens, Ade Gardner, Michael Shenton, Sia Soliola, Francis Meli, James Roby, James Graham, Tony Puletua, Jon Wilkin, Scott Moore, Louis McCarthy-Scarsbrook, Gary Wheeler, Matty Ashurst, Andrew Dixon, Jonny Lomax, Shaun Magennis, Jamie Foster, Tom Makinson, Scott Hale.

Wheres tinytim?

Jeez I am agreeing with MM on his selection.

Must lie down.

Same team as last week?

Hiding. The club's not happy.

Hopefully.

We need to try and get some consistancy in our selection and it'll be in the first time in a while(or so it seems) that we'll have kept the same 17 for 2 weeks on the trot.

I'd continue to ease Finchy in from the bench for a couple of weeks yet.