The million pound question is......can he catch a cold?

ball in hand - brilliant
ball on floor - solid
ball in air - poo in pants

Sums him up brilliantly

I hope the next thing he catches is the plane to Aus. We have better players chomping at the bit.

I'd still give him time.

You don't go from being "By far the best player in the Comp" to being a player you get rid with two years left on his contract.

The guy needs a try or two to get his confidence back and I think he will improve as the season goes on.

I agree, but who to drop when Sam comes back, if not Roberts?

I know what you mean but his head isn't there. He has all the skills in the world but without the mentality he will never use them. I really hope i'm wrong but i don't see Amos making a big mark on the team this season.

Sorry matt disagree his positional play is poor and he didn't make one attempt to catch a ball all night

He's had how many games in 21's + a few in sl but yet cant catch a bomb not being funny half of the people on here can take what he had tonight

He's a squad player, it's a long season...just keep rotating. If he improves (which I think he might), then he'll get back in at some point.

Matt IF is a massive word is sport

I see him as a winger going forward.

Last season he was injured / not 100% right right through to the off season.

I expect us to go through the same period of uncertainty with Paaat as well in a few weeks time, cause let's face it...he ain't going to be bouncing around like he was before the achilles injury.

Be patient my young padiwan.

He looked in a world of his own at times tonight, wandering around behind the line. I was actually impressed with him with the ball, looked dangerous. But I bet kris radlinski will have a few things to say about his efforts with the ball in the air. Saying that Brough can't half kick a ball, it comes down in a curve making it very difficult for the fullback.

He's a very good player, but I think he'll spend most of the season on the wing if and when others are injured or dropped (presuming sam stays at fullback).

Just a side note, when they got that no-try from the knock on in the second half, did Roberts turn round and question the referee as the hudds player turned and went for the line? Could have sworn he did, I thought that as the hudds player turned and headed towards the line Roberts was facing the other way. Could have imagined it though!

Come the end of the year and the possibility arises that he'd like to leave, I'd let him go. He's clearly a confidence player, and it's something he's lacking big time at present. He's just been to inconsistent for me during his time with us, from one extreme to the other.

What I'd hate to see is him holding back the development of King and Russel.

Dont tell me your a karl pryce fan