One of the best games ive seen , a joy to watch , poor conditions , shame there had to be a loser

Great spectacle - whatever! That was an atrocious game, would have said that win or lose.

Great to watch as a neitral.

The best team lost today, Wigan didn't deserve to lose. Sean O'Loughlin, Pat Richards, Sam Tomkins and even K Pryce were very good today.

If Bentham had been as willing to penalise Leeds as he was to penalise Wigan then Maguire's side would be in the semi-finals.

poor Martin missing that tackle at the end...

it was a heck of an arm wrestle...good advert for the game in terrible conditions.

Anyone notices bent ham shout tomkins is offside as pat kicks it? Would have sent to extra time if he hadnt missed that which chances are he wouldnt if he hadnt been put off that way.

to the bradfors fan. oloughlin got away with far too much messing around.it was a good game wigan switched off for 1 minute in that second half and u cant afford to do that. much tougher than our game last week cant wait for the next meeting

How did he get away with far too much? Got penalised for absolutely everything!!!

Even having his arm clamped between the ball by the Leeds player. Absolute tosh!!!!

Yeah, I heard it just as Pat was about to strike the ball.

The standard of refereeing was up to usual hopeless standard. It was obvious the guy was unwilling to penalise the Whinos as much as Wigan.

Have to admit though the penalties & dropped ball by both Coley & Prescott cost us dearly.

PS Was anyone else driven mad by Kear's obvious pro-Leeds commentary today, how on Earth could he have commented neutrally when the day before he'd tipped the Whinos to win the comp.

Unlucky today Wigan. Thought you probably had the best of it but we took one of the 2 chances we had. Very entertaining game.

Great game but its always dissapointing when a side who has played clearly better has lost due to inept referring.

We deserved to win that game so much and had it stolen.

Give over. We lost the game because we didnt convert our chances. The ref didn't make us lie on in the tackle, the ref didn't drop our passes & the ref didnt miss our kicks at goal.

Sinfield got penalised for exactly the same about 5minutes later so dont go too OTT about it.

I have a heart condition, and believe me, games like today don't help!!

Hope all have a safe journey home.

of course he didn't, theres no argument that we could have still won the game had we kept our composure,,,,, but include us missing j.tompkins for a period after being booted in the head..(something players have been easily binned for in the past....) and farrell being questionably sin binned.. and the game could of been very different.

i hope the players can take some positives from this and learn some lessons, but the best team lost. and to say its gutting would be an underestimation. but i guess thats rugby league....