Do we have any good one's. This mon refereeing the Saints v Catalan game hasnt a clue.

Hope we never get this mon in the cup.

Ask Justin Morgan?

I'd love to know why those two one-on-one wrestling matches were awarded as penalties to Saints. I couldn't work either of those decisions out, and neither could any of the commentators.

Still, at least he was consistant - as our refs usually are when they're at KR.

He should of called who's ball it was, giving the pen was stupid because Catalans had just as much of a shout for a pen as saints on both occasions.

The refs are spoiling it again mainly due to them probably never having played the game and just see things in absolute black and white, instead of letting the game flow and letting us see a good game with passion they are stop,start,stop,start Im the star of the afternoon type of thing with their arrogant attitude.

For instance,

The whole obstruction rule really needs to be looked at,as it is scaring teams from having dummy runners and the refs are ruling out perfectly good tries.

Why do they have to go to the video ref for evey decision?

What do the linesmen actually do apart from come onto the pitch when it is televised just to get their face on camera as they rarely do it when it isn't televised?

The refs seem to be on a timer to give penalties, when the game is in full flow and there hasn't been a penalty for a while the slightest thing and there is a penalty.

There also seems to be a lot of diving going on when the opposition team is playing the ball, the slightest touch from the defence the opposition player dives and gets a penalty, we don't want this in our game and its up to the refs to stop giving penalties for this and tell the players to get on with it.

The referees lack simple common sense and a basic understanding of the game, Mr Cummins needs to sort it out.

Rant Over!

Due to the refs giving obstruction for perfectly good tries, players are deliberately running into the oppositon player to con the ref or because of the stupid decisions made by the refs this provides a benchmark for what the obstruction rule means threfore fans with a good knowledge of the game are calling for obstruction and players are giving themselves up for obstruction when in fact there was nothing wrong with it. Perfect example for this was yesterday when Coley ran throughin front of Leuluai and Leuluai gave himself up and the ref gave obstruction................ even though Coley had gone through and affected no opposition player. It needs to be addressed!!!!!!!!!!!!

Due to the refs giving obstruction for perfectly good tries, players are deliberately running into the oppositon player to con the ref or because of the stupid decisions made by the refs this provides a benchmark for what the obstruction rule means threfore fans with a good knowledge of the game are calling for obstruction and players are giving themselves up for obstruction when in fact there was nothing wrong with it. Perfect example for this was yesterday when Coley ran throughin front of Leuluai and Leuluai gave himself up and the ref gave obstruction................ even though Coley had gone through and affected no opposition player. It needs to be addressed!!!!!!!!!!!!

Can't agree more with this topic!! Thought the ref yesterday was poor, left both teams lie on far too long which meant it had to turn into a forwrds battle as both defences were set. Did you hear him say after the Hock incident for the try 'The video ref is there so we should use him'. So does this mean that refs change their style of reffing wheter they are on tv or not????

Also I know that Russell Smith is doing a great job over in Oz teaching and training refs. Deffo a way forward to have him instead of Cummings.

Also has anyone noticed how quick the NRL has got since having two refs?? Think most of the Super League players would struggle to keep up.