Daryl Clarke in exchange for that nasty sneering 'limited ability' thug?? No thanks, Clarke is on a different planet.

Mcilorum ran 40mtrs to break Kirk dixons jaw at our place, week after week we see him and the other kray twin Bateman niggling and sneering at the opposition instead of playing rugby.

It may well be part and parcel of the game, but I expect more from a club with the tradition of the mighty Wigan, which is now sadly a team reduced to the thuggish tactics of some Sunday morning amateur teams.

Ill stick with the entertainers thank you (no matter where we finish - top 8 or bottom eight)
You can keep blindly defending your council park thugs

Clarke is a good player and will get better next season at Warrington.

Sneering Kray twins

A big fan of Micky Mac's aggression, strength and defence, but i'd just like to see a bit more intelligence and finesse when we're going forward. His distribution can be a bit off at times too...

Yep, pity for him that he's leaving a top 4 side to go to wire

Sneering Kray twins lol. I wouldn't swap either of them for any players you have at Dull KR come to think of it.

[urlhttp://www.wigantoday.net/sport/wigan-warriors/wane-pays-mcilorum-the-ultimate-compliment-1-6626497[/url

Massive compliment! Tez was one of my favourite Wigan players ever.

There are certainly similarities . . . . .



Newton a far more dangerous player IMO, in pretty much every sense of the word!

McIllorum is fantastic for us. He is unlike any other modern day hooker in that his primary role is to destroy. Which he does fantastically well (he now officially owns Roby). His running is better than he is given credit for - in the CC Final and the Grand Final he made vital breaks - and his distribution must be good enough, given how effective we are in scoring when he is on the pitch. The biggest thing about him is that he pretty much always out plays whoever he is opposite in big games. And that is a priceless asset. In contrast, Newton often saved his weaker performances for bigger games. Eye catching is not the same as effective.
Mac will have a more glittering career than Newton, and will be a far better for Wigan.

Maybe one day he will own roby's England shirt, although he didn't make a great stab at it in the world cup

Let's be realistic. MM is a fantastic player for us, I'm one of his biggest fans but he does have his limitations. He may well have outplayed Roby in the derby games recently but the whole Wigan team has outplayed St Helens. Roby is a better all round rugby player, his scoot has obviously good but over the years he has matured into a world class player IMO.

I would love Wigan to sign a creative hooker with a bit more pace (such as a Roby or a Clark, possibly even a Burrow) as I think the two styles would complement each other and it would offer something different. MM to start and the other of the bench. MM can offer cover & rotation for the back row and loose, he's proven to be more then capable of both.