Defensively he is awful and that has been highlighted in the last two televised games. His read of whats in front of him is often wrong and leaves his team mates inside him exposed. He took his try well last night and came back well on the angle from Sowoods pass but that is nothing I wouldnt expect for a super league player. He should be a long way off a starting jersey if he has signed. Alot of work to do.

Me too!

Sarginson is only twenty years of age. He appears to have the raw talent, he had a superb game for London v Wigan a couple of years ago.
He reminds me very much of Stefan Ratchford in his versatility and running style. As a few have alluded to he looks poor defensively, but he's playing in a very poor side at the moment.
Would he go better with better players around him? Probably.
Is he worth taking a risk on? I would say yes if the salary is right.

I don't see another player in our junior ranks who has that flexibility to play at #1, #3, #4, #6 and #7.

Surely Sam Panapa must have had a son by now...

I don't see how we can judge anyone in that London team, even Soward looked crap against us. Different kettle of fish at Wigan, if we have signed him I'm looking forward to seeing him play for us.

But is that necessary? We have Hampshire and Tierney who can play 1, Gelling, Thornley, Burgess and (at a push) Hughes who can play 3/4, and we have Hampshire, Powell and Williams in the halves. Who cares if no one man covers all of those positions?

Perhaps we will be selling more players so IL can line his pockets.....

the problem defensively isnt that he plays in a poor team. He makes bad reads and leaves his team exposed. That is his choice not one forced on him by his team mates. He needs to learn how to read the game, study the opposition and put that into match practice. Attacking wise he is exciting but he needs educating.

That's the problem. The raw talent will stagnate and wither in the London team, being poorly coached and motivated and playing with Aussies out for a holiday. Look at Chubb, now 25 and going nowhere. 20 is a good age to still be coached and moulded in the right environment.

Chris Taylor would give you a run for your money!!

Yes, and educating is something we seem to do particularly well at, judging by the youngsters we're producing! At his age, it would be unfair to expect the finished product. He's younger than either Thornley or Gelling, and IMO has more potential than either of them.

Looks very poor IMO. His defence in recent weeks has been nothing short of utter shocking. He's playing in poor side so can't help but IMO he's not Wigan class player.

I hope you sign him

Possibly playing in a poor team is the reason for his poor form but that doesn't stop him making one on one tackles.

His defensive stats are no worse than Jordan Turner. Gelling gave him a torrid time at Saints a couple of weeks back.