Tomkins was very good tonight. He had a very similar game to last year and played the conditions very well.

Impressed with Williams also (especially in defence) apart from one shocking pass on the last tackle to Smith that he knocked on.

Good options.

Yup he stepped up tonight, he must hate Warrington, that's two great games he's had against them now.

McIlorum's ban will be a blessing in disguise. MM is such a durable player and Logan is doing fine given a rare starting spot.

Good performance from Logan. He was quick into dummy half, his decision making was good and he tackled well too. He's unlikely to just have a brilliant season out of nowhere, he'll continue to improve gradually and become more consistent until he reaches his best.

Thought he was very good last night

The Warrington game was the best performance that I have seen from Logan by a country mile. I have to say that I have never been that impressed by him previously and didnt think he would have much of a future at Wigan but a few more games like that will certainly change that view.

Very good game from Logan

It's sad sometimes that some people on this board are so very quick to be critical. The lad is living under the shadow of his brothers to some extent, and playing in a position thats at the heart of the action. He is still young, and does an acceptable job in my eyes... He can only get better. MM, when new, was constantly slated on here, probably by those who now laud him.

I have to say I was very critical of MM but because he deserved it. When he first made the 17 he was very one dimensional, it's a credit to the coaching staff and him that he has become a much more balanced player.

Logan is in the same boat for me. He has struggled and looked poor at times in the past, but every year he has improved. At the start of the year I actually expected him and Crosby to be our "bolters" this year, and whilst not as yet achieving that I think he has really played well so far and is becoming an asset rather than a liability that he once was.

Thankfully, those in the know, know more that we do... I enjoy watching how young players adapt and grow, it's all a part of the pleasure of watching for me....

he did everything a good hooker should do.....passed, ran and passed, scooted when the chance was there, and tackled anything that moved.
Its a confidence thing. Getting some rare starts is showing the doubters what he can do.
His tackling more text book than big hits, but that will come when he bulks up.
I'm quite happy to let him develop as Maccas understudy, and one day i reckon the roles will reverse

his best game , in my humble opinion , was against widnes last year when he was unlucky not to get MOM

not convinced by tomkins at all. i think he has been given more of a chance than others purely because his name is tomkins. when watching him i just feel like any other player could probably do exactly the same job. All he literally does is pass and tackle. he rarely creates anything!

I was impressed by him this week and definately ahead in the pecking order over Powell as back up to MM. Powell's distribution off the floor was poor agaoinst Hudds, taking a step before passing most of the time, and not in a way to draw the marker. Logan is off the floor first time and accurate with it. Not in ths same league as MM but definately capable perform to decent standard so MM can be spelled or rotated.

I'm always wary of criticising young front rowers. They often need more time to develop. IMO he's probably where MM was at his age. We'll have to wait and see if he keeps improving.