I do kind of agree, however, Is this not the risk you take for the chance of a break? By all means he is not going to get away with it every time he tries. however its the risk he takes and it seems to pay off when its really needed. Sometimes i think "You greedy so and so!" but then again, i think when he scores a try..What if hed have passed and it wasnt a try? double ended sword for me!... Still. Watching him run through warrington like that was immense... Still shaking my head at the beauty of it!

People have said he isn't as good a runner as Slater. I know who I would have in my team after today.

Slater rips open SOO, NRL and International defences.... Tomkins rips open SL defences, big difference.

considering his age..i feel as if the next few years will change people views - feel free to quote me! get him in a decent England squad and the rest will take care of its self..phenomenal

Slater also drops more than the odd clanger. But yeah, Sam is British and plays for WIgan so clearly it's all hype.

No slater is just better as he proved at International level... If Jarryd Hayne played in SL he would be the top try scorer every season, and score tries like Sams today for fun, the backs in the NRL are just far better than their SL eqivalents.

sam does that.

You're right, Sam's not actually that good.

Doesn't say much for Wire then, that he took the proverbial p:ss out of you lot and skinned your defence alive a few times today, does it?

Carmont the second rate Aussie who is Samoan and was captain of Samoa when we signed him.

St. george wasnt that impressive with all things considered. the better team maybe. but wasnt an australia vs england performance.

With ease? All of a 6 point win? Only a clueless blinkered monobrowed idiot would say St George found that game easy or Wigan were never in it.

And is this the same Carmont who was the subject of a Newcastle Knights petition to keep him at the club? Must be a second-rate player for them to want him to stay so much.

Your team was dismantled by an average Tomkins and second-rate Carmont.

Ok the second rate NRL player, who grew up in NZ but chose to play for Samoa as he wasn't good enough for the NZ team.

Also the best centre in the league?

I just cant get enough, I just cant get enough
All the things you do to me and everything you said
I just cant get enough, I just cant get enough


ever since the WCC...Performed week in week out. Anybody that cant recognise his performances are deluded, I've given praise to the likes of roby and Monaghan just as i feel carmont deserved it. anyone that disagrees is deluded or anti wigan, simple.. those 3 have performed outstanding for each club and if MoS was as fair as it should be, they would all be favs or 2favs!

Georgous george!

Yes great, but where have I said either Carmont or Tomkins haven't been great this season, or aren't great SL players.... I said Tomkins isn't as good as arguably the best back in the world in Billy Slater.... and George Carmont was a second rate NRL player... neither of those means they aren't very good SL players.