Nothing official yet but it's been rumoured for about 3 years.

Thanks, he may well end up at wire but if it's not official it's never a certainty

Cas have a great combination of hookers in Milner and Clarke, both excellent young players who compliment themselves very well.

Clarke for me is far superior to Roby who in comparison to Clarke is fairly one dimensional. Don't get me wrong Roby is very good but Clarke is something else.

He has definatley signed for Wire by the way although rumour is now he is trying to wriggle out of it, Cas took a big wedge for him a year or so back when they had a bit of financial trouble.

Yes.

I'm shocked you right him so highly above Roby but each to their own I suppose.

I'm sure your opinion would be the same if Roby wasn't a Saints player.

Roby is a player who is clearly very talented and a great SL player, one of the best but I think Clarke could well be considered World Class at the end of his career.

I don't doubt that at all mate, I'm just not sure he is there just yet that's all.

If you were prepared to let Roby go to Bradford, I'd happily do a swap deal with McIlorum.

Stats lie. Just going back one game to the Leeds game MM should be awarded an assist for Wigan's first try. He made it with his dominant run and quick play the ball. Just one example.

To answer the OP, for Wigan I'm wouldn't swap him with anyone however I would happily fake a Roby, Clark or Lunt to come off the bench.

So if you get a quick play the ball in the tackle prior to a try then you should get an assist?

The truth is somewhere inbetween. He's nowhere near as bad as opposition fans claim, he's underrated in that regard.

But he's probably not as good as some wigan fans make out either.

I like him as a hooker and would take him at leeds. He's clever and aggressive. He doesn't have the running game the likes of roby have, but they don't have his guile.

1st October 2011, the last time Roby got the better of MM in a head to head.