I was impressed with Hodgson for KR, if Wigan were looking at a hooker I'd be tempted to go for him!

If we are looking for a back up hooker look no further than Daryl Clark at Castleford.

47 tackles from Logan yesterday, almost 50% more than any other Wigan player.

If you were a Rovers forward you'd want to run at Tomkins all night long. It seems that's exactly what they did.

As you know I'm not his biggest fan, but I thought he went o.k. on Friday.

during and immediately after the match my opinion of Tomkins' performance was pretty shoddy, but having read all of these comments I can see the truth in the arguments in his favour too...
however, he has had 3 seasons or so now working with the likes of MM, TL and MH who are all great hookers in my opinion on their day, but Logan doesn't seem to be picking up off them and never has shown any real potential. he has had many chances to prove his worth but in fairness he hasn't had a good run of games either. Being in for 3 games is all well and good due to a ban but as soon as MM is available again he'll be back in the doldrums and that can't help his progression.
I honestly can't see where he is going to fit in the team over the next few years and as many have said on here, fair play to him, but he just hasn't got enough for Wigan, perhaps even a few lesser teams.
he suffers from being a "Tomkins" yes, but I have always argued that joel was the most talented and had the most potential out of the three anyway. and whether he was a Tomkins or not my opinion of him wouldn't be any different.
hopefully he can put in a couple of good performances but I can't see him shining against Wire - I'd love it to happen though!!
I'm happy to get behind him and give him a chance, I'm just doubtful he can deliver.

He had a superb game there last year, probably his best for Wigan.

How can we judge Logan when he hardly ever starts?
He started off slowly v HKR but picked up when the game had been going a while.
I reckon his quick shoot from dh put the team on the front foot for the Farrell try.
The HKR right defence was caught with one player moving up and another staying in the line.
The 9 these days is the busiest man on the field and he proved it with 47 or so tackles and he didn't do the 80.
To critisise him on his first start and just four games in is over the top IMO.

yes I think I remember Wane claiming moral victory despite the result!



lets hope he can replicate some good form in MMs absence. at the end of the day I'm more than happy to be proved wrong about him, and any other player I may have negative opinions on for that matter.

believe!

Cracking performance again, missed him massively when he went off especially his delivery, fronted up physically tonight too.

Williams showed some nice touches but he must work on his passing.

Tomkins was very good tonight. He had a very similar game to last year and played the conditions very well.

Impressed with Williams also (especially in defence) apart from one shocking pass on the last tackle to Smith that he knocked on.

Good options.

Yup he stepped up tonight, he must hate Warrington, that's two great games he's had against them now.