My girlfriend is Jamaican. Yes I'm a member of the BNP. You're an imbecile.

Again, I'll ask you to show where I claimed that Tomkins was better than Billy Slater. I merely said they (he and Carmont) aren't 2nd rate. other than your own misguided opinion, I'd like to see some sort of evidence that supports this claim.

I'm not "moaning at you". I'm merely pointing out what an imbecile you are. To be frank, you're doing a far better job of that than I ever could.

Sam is an outstanding talent mate and I understand you pies have tinted glasses but there a lots of players who are the talent tomkin is and some are a level above him

Beale
Gardner
Barba
carney
Cherry-evens
Dugan
Hoppauati
Hayne
Boyd
Widdop
Idris
Hoffman
Pearce
Morris
Kenny-dowall
Foran
Sandow
Blair
Jennings
Slater
Soward
Marshal
Stewart
Bowen
Smith
Gidley
Thurston
Cronk
Prince
Lockyer
Lyon
Gasnier
Gallen
Scott
Sims
Snowden

There are plenty of amazing players in the game young and old. As outstanding in sl as tomkin is he has plenty to do.

Where did I say Tomkins was second rate?

Is me saying Tomkins isn't as good as Slater translate in your mind to me saying his second rate, is this is why you're so upset.





Look I have lost interest in what you have to say, you keep lying and putting words in my mouth.

The feeling's mutual.

When you ask reasonable posters offensive questions such as are they members of the BNP then you make it clear that you are not interested in a sensible discussion.

Bad argument as half your team has played in the NRL and done well there yet you cant win the league....

The same second rate Carmont who ripped open the St George defence and raced 65 yards to score?! If that's second rate then second rate is good enough for me.

disagree with a lot of them, you need to have only fullbacks too.

You're starting to show yourself up a bit now. It would help if you knew anything about a) RL, and b) geography before making that silly Carmont comment. St George beat us by 6 points in the WCC. I'd hardly describe that as "dismantling" unless I was desperately grasping at straws. And who scored our two tries that day, you know against the world champions? It wouldn't be our second rate New Zealand-born Samoan "Aussie" would it? He's just rubbish isn't he?

Better than Offiah's at wembley

Not only that, but what a stupid game to pick if he's trying to make out George isn't a world class player. George played very well indeed against St George, giving the St George defence problems all through the game. He looked to be one of the best players on the park.

No no no. There are lots of oustanding talents in many positions of tomkin standard and at the next level coming through in oz every year or are seasoned pro's I could have added more thaiday, yow ye, civonaciva. The point is tomkin is the outstanding talent in SL but the NRL is full of outstanding talent.

Outstanding talent ripping it up against outstanding talent week in week out.

The fullback thing you mention is a good point to discuss. There is still big debate amongst pies about tomkin as a 1 or a 6 he has a lot of development to go in which is his best position, defence, kicking and ball playing! Marshal has played winger, fullback, a fair bit at centre, 6 as well as 7! I didn't even put inglis on the list! His best position is regarded as fullback but there is talk of madge moving him back to 6 where he played a season and a half for the storm but he has played a lot a centre! Thurston is a 7 but is gonna be the origin 6! Boyd plays wing, centre , 6 but has been turned into a fullback but the word is he will be the knights 6. the best outstanding talents are diverse! Tomkin would be another awesome talent amongst many in the NRL with much development to go. In SL he is pretty much the only outstanding young British talent. Some of you pies already have him infront of slater? Who is regarded as the best. Tomkin is awesome but has some way to go.

Agree 10000000%