This is the 2nd thread I've had to clean up because of 7 year olds throwing snot at each other. Grow up or I'll tell your mum you're up after bedtime because the babysitter is gash.

Maguire brought half the Melbourne team with him. Didn't have a squad of academy players.
Oh and didn't he leave the ´ biggest´ club in rugby for bigger and better things?
I should study more. Your not behind wire in grand final wins. Have they won more challenge cups in the modern era than Wigan?
6-3 would be........double the amount ie twice as many, twice as far....way ahead.

Maguire won the GF with the addition of Paul Deacon. HTH.

Hoffman and Lima were already at Wigan then?

Yes, and two hardly constitutes "Half"...

No

No.

As an FC fan, still not convinced former prop forwards make the best coaches
Wane was lucky to inherit the strong foundation put in place by MM.
It would have been hard for any coach to fail with what he was left with.
Now, after a few years, his true influence is being felt.
Trouble is, if you get rid of him won't Deacon just take over?. I always thought that was your owners long term plan.
Can't you try and poach Radford off us?

Coaches like SW have a limited shelf-life. Shouting and swearing will only motivate players for so long before the influence starts to wear off. I'm not saying that's all SW has in his locker, but he seems to sit in the motivational coach camp, rather than the technical guru camp.

We've had years of coaches telling us that success would come once they had "their team"
My argument is that MM hardly signed anyone for you and yet turned you into champions.

I could only remember them. There was another Melbourne player.
The point which you clearly are deliberately avoiding is Maguire had a far far far better squad.
Stick with Wane he's building a seriously good team out of your academy. Which he's had a lot of input in.
You've lost 2 games grow up all of you. Before that you didn't concede a point in 160 mins.

I'm not ready to join the Wane out brigade yet - we've played some of our best rugby in a long time under his coaching. However he needs to keep his mouth firmly shut and stop giving the opposition team talk for them. He's also got three games to sort out the appalling away performances that are going to kill the season unless something changes. Three poor defeats at Newcastle v Leeds, at Huddersfield and Stains and his position will be untenable.

Lima, Hoffman and Finch joined after Maguire won his only GF with us.

Did MM inherit a great team at Souths as well then?
Bit of a coincidence he's gone back to the NRL and done exactly what he did here.

Wrong again.

Madge took over a team that finished 6th the season before and took them to the title with only one addition in Paul Deacon.

Challenge Cup wins is 3 each with us and Wire. So will you admit we are way ahead of them them?

Also apart from you who mentioned the biggest club in the world? I actually said we aren't the best side in SL

You seem to either not know what you talking about, love clutching at straws or you're a bad troll.