IL won't sack Wane midway through a season.

IMO part of the reason for that is IL is wary of the reputation Wigan had as a club that was very fickle when it came to this and doesn't want it to have the same reputation under his stewardship.

The other reason he won't sack him IMO is he has given Wane a two year deal and so will give him that time to show whether he is up to the job or not. A deal is a deal so to speak. So the question is, I reckon, will Wane get a new deal at the end of 2013, not will he be sacked during the season?

How IL will decide that I don't know. Getting to semi-finals didn't get Noble another contract in 2009 but it could be argued as we have a poorer side on paper it would be unfair to expect better from Wane next year than this. I suspect though that Wane won't be able to count on that to come to his rescue if things go badly wrong.

In all honesty I could see Nathan Brown going home before SW!

Not surprised by this. We have lost some top class players and replaced them with weaker signings or filling their gaps with young players. Our season is unlikely to be as strong as last season and therefore pressure will be on after poor recruitment with so much free cap space. Lets hope the team can perform ok

IL won't sack Wane, but if we have a poor season I could see him possibly stepping down back to Assistant Coach. I think he was made for that role personally. I don't think we'll be far off the trophies again though.

I would give Wane another year. Hopefully he WILL learn from last year, put less emphasis on the rounds and peak next September.

If he fails to grasp this simple point he needs to be shown the door.

Yep

its as easy as 1,2,3

Does Wane have to win the Superleague or Challenge Cup next season to win your seal of approval or would getting to one of the finals do?

Trouble with our fans is that if we "did a Leeds" and finished lower down in the regular season yet got to both finals and won one of them, they'd still all be unhappy cos we finished so low down the table. Can't win really!

Not for one minute do I think Wane will not be gunning for top spot.

Whilst I think he may try different ways to spell senior players in lesser games and try new methods in training to give the team a greater chance of peaking at the business end of the season no way can I see him deliberately forfeiting top spot (if the chance is there). It's not in his nature i'm afraid.

In that case he will never be a top class coach under the current rules of SL.

Yes he does. This is Wigan RL we are talking about, not St Pats Under 18s.

A schoolboy could work out that it is the playoffs that are vital under the current structure. If Wane cannot then he needs to be removed.

There is no denying his passion and he is a very likeable guy, but he really must learn from his first season in charge. There is absolutely no point in thrashing teams in Feb, only to falter in Sept.

You can top the league and then go on to win a Grand Final you know.

It is pointless being so absolute. You just make yourself look foolish.

You said the same about Madge and see how that turned out.

I appreciate his dedication to Wigan but find him easily dislikeable. I am not sure there are many outside Wigan who do.

Didn't Noble get criticised by some Wigan fans for not getting the "Week in Week out performances" right and instead focussing too much on "Being Right come Play off time"?

Maybe he was right after all?

That would say more about people who dislike anything or anyone assosicated to Wigan RL than it does about him?