He'll be at a more disciplined environment (I'd imagine) at Wigan.

So long as he can keep his cool and do what he does best, he'll be a good signing.

god people do get jumped on here for having a differing view,
terrible signing in my opinion, and its not even confirmed so its not happened yet

We have enough props, and each are better than him.

We also have 1 retiring, and 2 who will be coming back off long term injuries.

n they are still better than him,

Hands up who would rather have Cross?

o/

why do we insit on signing other teams cast-offs

id much rather have cross n i was strongly against him coming

IMO we don't need him, but i'm willing to give him a chance.

It's not for having a different view it's the inaccuracies in your post about him being a penalty machine, which you now must admit was wrong.

Just out of curiosity , how many times have you seen him play?

I don't know if he will be a good signing or not, I'll wait and see him play in a Wigan jersey before making my judgement.

Or you could be paying top salary to Perry for not playing?

Unless developed by our academy, EVERY player is "another team's cast-off".

stop being argumentative,
christ,
i said i didnt want him, i stand by that, stop trying to force my opinion the opposite way,

ive seen him everytime hull have been on tv, and i do not think he plays well, dont think he will offer us anything.

maybe he could pull a rabbit out of his ass

I'm not trying to be argumentative - I haven't seen enough of him to form an opinion (If it ain't Wigan, I don't pay attention to individual players).

All I'm saying is that the idea of other team's cast-offs is a strange one as it could be levelled at almost every player we have.

And if you're suffering from a sense of humour breakdown, can I suggest either staying home tonight (as you'll end up frustrated by the over-zealous stewarding) or just getting bladdered so you can ignore them.

If we play the Rhinos and Rob Burrow kicks off he will be a useful addition

Now if we still had Feka here, he could pull an extra prop out of his ass, with the current size of it.

That would definitely help us out.

Sadly, I feel, he'd be criticized for that also.

As I said do you still think he's a penalty machine?
You are entitled to your opinions, I'm in the wait and see camp.

But in the past you have also told us, we should have kept Phelps, Sam is better at six, Finch should be dropped as he was crap, and that Hoffman was over rated.

i stand by 3 out of 4 of those comments, stand corrected on hoffman,

Now B I thought you liked to bring your own young players through at Wigan. I can't understand this signing at all as I thought you werewell off in that dept. I know Coley is retiring and Fieldon isn't what he was but I thought you had a good crop of homegrown in that dept.

Finch has been outstanding the last 5 or 6 weeks so why would you drop him??

Why do you think Sam is bette at 6?

We have two "promising" young props in Crosby and Spencer, but they are both under 20 so expect they'll be out on loan next year(How many 20 year old props do you know playing Superleague) I can see the reasoning behind the signing, just as I could with the short term signing of Cross, particularly as you say with Coley retiring and the uncertainty with Fielden and indeed O'Carroll.

Is Lauaki good enough? I honestly don't know, but I'm in the wait and see camp, tbh I think a centre is top priority but there aren't any around (IL, please find us another George Carmont)

We may have not signed him as a prop.

cos i think sam gets signled out to much at full back, and i think sam is good enough to make the space in the middle, and would cause more confusion there, its MY OPINION so do not try and change it!

and as for funch he has been good not get me wrong i just feel he is still making too may mistakes, and seems to miss-read teh game a bit for me, throws lots of interception passes or ones begging to be intercepted and his kicking game seems to be a bit lacking, in regards to his choice of kick at the correct time.

Again its my opinion, not fact, my opinion!

Is he our new coach?