Thought it was a try. Both Briers and Westwood got to the man anyway so neither were 'taken out'. Was a superb dummy runner move.

but the rest of the game last week summed you up

oh good thanks, not just me then thought perhaps I was being blinkered.

Good to watch. The pathetic attempted tackle on Carlaw for his try was another one well worth watching again!

I agree that disallowed try early in the second half should have been given, too.
Fortunately it didn't affect the result.

I thought both of Catalans' tries that were disallowed by the video ref were, in fact, tries.
Conversely, Warrington's first try began with a knock-on, not a charge down.
The game just showed how much effort Wire put in against Wigan. An effort they obviously could not sustain.

Seen this said a few times now.

Didn't Wigan put any effort in last Friday then?

of course they put loads of effort into last week. Difference is they could maintain the effort the week after, Wire clearly couldn't.

And that proves what?

We haven't lost back to back games all season

but we could contain you and beat you, you couldnt handle it obviously. and we nearly beat catalan

Well as the saying goes "you are only as good as your last game" and the league table shows we are four points clear. The other saying is "the table doesnt lie"!

Not as much as Wire. It seemed their lives depended on it. Reminded me of GB against OZ. We give our all but can't sustain it.
Yes Wire are like GB (England) but Wigan are like Australia.

I don't even think we gave our all last Friday we can play miles better

Wigan were big favs for that game not just because you are top and at home but because we were in a bit of bad form maybe we still are.

Not really though, both sides defended well, including us in the first 20 minutes. Thats a credit to the defense of both teams. It was close and either team could of won, but we edged it, just.
Cant you accept that

I can accept it, I fully expected a wire victory last week although I was two points out with my prediction. I don't think after two games there is anything to seperate the two teams when they play each other which is why I'd rather not play them again this year. The point is Wire got the two points last week which point them in a great position to challenge for top spot and they gave those two points straight back last night.
Its just as important to back up after a win as it is after a defeat.

Wigan should never have been favourites and certainly weren't big favourites. Any Wigan fan knows your pack is bigger than ours, how much of a difference Coley makes to us in big games, how much we miss Piggy when he goes off particularly when McIlorum is injured and that we are top of the league because of the expansive rugby we can play when the conditions are good. It was your biggest game of the season because you hoped you could avoid Saints in the playoffs but you showed you can't follow up a tough game with a decent performance so you might as well not bother about the playoffs anyway.

Just seen the highlights and LOL @ Mathers for Catalans first try after half time, that bloke is unbelievably sh*t

Considering the great performances we are getting of late from Gleeson and the fact we got rid of that waste of space Mathers at the same time, it only shows what a fantastic bit of business IL made (even including the 100k fee)!!

Where can I see the highlights?

You think we played anything like we can?

Come on quit with the excuses you beat us on the night well done but we have been the better team all season the table doesn't lie

But i forgot when we win it's cause the other team made us look good isn't it?

Wire had an 8 point start with the bookies.

but you showed you can't follow up a tough game with a decent performance

Seem to remember us having a tough game against you then going to Hudds and winning

as well not bother about the playoffs anyway





Clueless

I bet against Wigan with 4 start before I knew anything about the weather,but in any case why are you bringing up something that happened earlier in the season? After all I thought early season form meant nothing by the way your lot are writing us off. Seems you can give it but can't take it without resorting to schoolboy insults. The way you're celebrating still about beating us by only 7 points after how poor we were shows you're really nothing special but if you read some of my other posts you'll see that I think any of the top 4 are in with a chance its just that you might have to do it the hard way and hope you don't meet Saints again in a knockout game.

Just to prove your comment was utter crap.

Who's writing you off?

Quite a few pundits last week said we had burned out, peaked too soon. Then we go to 4th placed team who've only lost 1 home game this year dont concede 1 point and score 46.

Why bother listening to them they have been writing us off after every defeat.

Ok, you really aren't capable of discussing something without throwing out personal insults are you?