That's a new one.

Even on TotalRL - which is superficially a neutral site, though most of its posters still hate Wigan - they are saying the same thing. Had the incident occurred earlier on and had it not been a Leeds v Wigan situation, there would have been no further comment.

Leeds seem to have a huge self-pity thing going on at present, which I suspect stems from being stunned at how quickly they've fallen from grace. The attempts to blame Wigan players for McGuire's injury last season, the private meetings to discuss other clubs' tactics. the ludicrous overreaction to the Lima tackle, and now this - all smack of a club striking out because they are basically in a daze.

Of course, comments in the media have helped fuel their outrage. There are two things you can be sure of: a) Had a Wigan player dropped that ball and had his resulting 'score' disallowed, there would have been no mention of contoversy in the RL press. b) There would have been none from the Wigan fans either.

I fear every team. You aren't special enough to be the one I fear most!

It was a knock on, always has always will be. It's a knock on in the amateur game the junior game and the professional game!

You my friend are deluded.

Surely it becomes a judgement call on what the player intended to do, just like whether a player plays the ball or the ball plays him when effecting a tackle decides whether its a knock on or not?

The example you give would be a clear knock-on.

My penny's worth (and I know your all waiting on it with baited breath) is that even given Cumming's "liberal" interpretation of the rules the McGuire incidence was a knock-on as he was not attempting a drop goal; he was looking to grubber through (I can't believe some people on this thread are suggesting he was not committed to a kick through and reacted to droppping the ball - get down to Specsavers if you do) and could not execute the kick correctly due to the pressure he was under. This lead to a hash of the attempted kick and a knock-on occurring.

Right we give in it was a try. Get Mr H to get the table adjusted asap. Dont fear Leeds, your players raised their game twice and took a point! We only showed up for 20mins and your cricket ground car park and half a game at DW.
If and its a big if, we were to fear anyone Wire are the only ones and they are beatable esp if we turn up as did agaisnt Huddersfield!

Your spot on! He dropped the ball attempting to kick it but he dropped it! Ofcourse leeds next game will see danny show us that this is how he normally kicks!

+1.... Made me smile.....

Your assessment is fair enough, but it's a bit sad that we all have to keep evaluating and re-evaluating this incident. Whether he was trying a grubber, whether he fumbled - all irrelevant. It was a knock-on. It was very clearly NOT an attempted field-goal. That should be the end of the matter, though I suspect it won't be - that will only come when Leeds next lose, and their fans need to look for a different excuse.

But I have to mention one thing that is killing me. All fo a sudden Stuart Cummins is a font of all knowledge.

People have very short memories. He was far and away the worst ref in modern times. He's the only I know whose performance was so bad that he got taken out on the pitch by a fan, during a professional match.

He is probably the reason that all the other refs are so bad at times. HE is in charge.

I was impressed with the ref in the championship game last night, he should get a shot at super league. Very impressive!

Really? I thought he was pretty poor.

Watch all the dirty tackles of the 90s on You tube, only then will you realise how bad Cummings was as a referee, how and who put him in charge?