I was bringing to the table, in a between the lines kind of way that McIlorum is proven(as Roby has done), by what he had achieved. Clarke is a beltin player, but if he never wins anything stats that you quoted don't really matter. By all means bring this back in August, or October.
And as for personal insults, I'm not going to sit back and let you call me crazy.

If that's what you want, then tell us the attributes you want to compare.

Anything relevant really. There could be a whole host of different things you could look at, including:

Creativity
Distribution
Errors
Tackles
Missed Tackles
Kicking Game
Penalties Conceded

Those things are far more relevant than medals won when comparing the ability if two different players. Medals are won by a team, not by one player.