Quote: jonh "I really hope we do not become a club that tries to live off Madges legacy if he does go, ie promoting from within every time. Wane has perhaps earned his stripes, but a third generation rarely works as the principles become watered down and dated.
See Bradford after Brian Smith for the perfect example of this.
New ideas are essential to keep a club moving forward. You rarely if ever get new ideas from clones.'"
Have I misunderstood your point (it is Late)?
Brian Smith spent one year at Bradford and won nothing
the second generation i.e Matthew Elliot won a superleague title and a Challenge Cup
and then The third generation Brian Noble Won everything.... lots of times....
I dont think your argument is a good one