Two years ago, we played JC at Full Back against Warrington in the play-offs and yes, he was good, he got a try and we nearly won, but had Scott Grix been playing, we would have won. In these game, we have fine margins and that fine margin can be someone experienced who can return the ball and contribute to attack solidly and unspectacularly, but knows the systems we play and has experience with the back line and the halves.

I know it's not popular, but my money is for Scott Grix at full back next week. I'll happily take any criticism for having this opinion, it's just mine and I'm putting it out there. He's not our full back for the next 5 years, just for the next 5 days. Sometimes, you have to make tough calls like telling a 19 year old he needs to sit this one out, but let him know he'll be a Fartown Full Back soon and if he works hard, he can be an absolute Giant (pardon the pun) of the club.

Simple fact is Grid is yet to have a good game this season

Simpson isn't

And ive defended Grix a long time

I would say Grix has played well this season. He has cut down on the silly mistakes and is playing solid if unspectacular rugby.

The thing with Grix is he rarely has a standout game, he's solid most games without appearing briliant but every mistake he makes the crowd is on his back straight away and his head goes down and that's his game done. When he's solid and doesn't make big howlers he's absolutely fine. He's probably had a few 'good' games but non one tends to notice what he does unless it's the bad things !!.

Personally i thought Jared was a breathe of fresh air and a joy to watch, there was a sense of anticipation akin to when Paul Reilly was no1 when he got the ball - we don't have that with Grix just safety and steadiness.
With these 2 plus Jake Connor, who also has looked great at fullback when he's played there, there is definitely enough competiton to give Baloo headaches.
If it was a vote i'd keep Jared in as his confidence must be through the roof after that debut !.

I've got an idea to solve all the arguments why don't we just pay off Scott Grix's contract and anyone other than him can have a go at playing fullback. Better still Jaryd Hayne will be available soon when he fails in the NFL. We could make him our marquis signing ?

How he recovers from the Wigan game will play it's part. Super League is far tougher than the 19's.
Two SL games against top teams in seven days may be a step too far at this point.
I'm sure the coaching team will consider all the facts and decide accordingly.

jared is only part time, think we need to sign him up soon!

We were all singing the praises of Connor a few weeks ago, the last few have seen quite a few negative comments about him. SL is a faster game than U19, and the training will be harder- that could explain Connors downturn. Simpson hasn't even been training with the squad so let's not get too far ahead with him.....

Baloo said on the radio that the whole team were amazed at some of the things he was doing, so it seems he has done some training with the 1st team.

jared plays again !!!

The examiner interview with jared was rather good. He came across very well! Rather humble and thanked Scott grix for helping him. Mentioned he expected Scott to take back the spot from him but not dishearted!

In my opinion contract length, loyalty, experience, ect should all be put the side for form.

When grix came in for Connor he chimed into the line good support play but that is no watched and sussed in each of the last few games. He is marked and as he isn't running with conviction and looking for the pass as an extra pivot often left with no where to go but the floor.

Jared came in and delt with high bombs as well as grix,
One on one situations better than grix, ran the ball back hard rather than looking for a winger, had a step, dooked and dived. Just looked lively and to be enjoying the chance!

For me we should keep him in! The experience will do him the world of good and if I had to choose who was likely to do more for the team at the moment it's him!

Also would say wires kicking game isn't as good as Wigans so should be less pressure on him.