Quote Quickening="Quickening"He is a liability defensively, prone to errors and doesn't make good metres with ball in hand... Being fast doesn't make you a good winger.
Why people act as though Smith has some vendetta against penny is baffling, Russell and lineham are both comfortably better players.
I could see an argument for penny over evans on the wing because evans doesn't offer anything in attack.'"
I'm sorry, but your first 5 words are complete testicles (imo), if you're comparing him to any other wingers in SL. He's no more a liability than anyone else. More a convenient excuse to be used, when any tries are scored within 10M of his touchline. FFS, I've seen him "hung out to dry" by the Beatified Matt King, more times than I care to mention (particularly that incident @Stains, about 7 years ago).
Yes, he misses tackles, every winger does. I've also seen him put in some crackers.
If you think Russell is a better winger than Penny, I advise you take more water with your preferred drink. Opinions, like ar5eholes, we've all gottem, some of them stink (no offence

)