FORUMS FORUMS






RLFANS.COM
Celebrating
25 years service to
the Rugby League
Community!
  
FORUMS > Warrington Wolves > Query - Mathers' "mess up" and McGuire's "try
17 posts in 2 pages 
<<   PREV  NEXT   >>
RankPostsTeam
Player Coach1341No
Team
Selected
JoinedServiceReputation
Aug 200717 years
OnlineLast PostLast Page
Dec 2011Dec 2011LINK
Milestone Posts
0
100
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Signature
34753_1277062598.gif
[url=http://www.fishsta.co.uk:2vgqqjxt][img:2vgqqjxt]http://img844.imageshack.us/img844/1839/wwwfishstacoukbanner.jpg[/img:2vgqqjxt][/url:2vgqqjxt]:d7dc4b20b2c2dd7b76ac6eac29d5604e_34753.gif



I don't fancy trawling through all the posts on here after the Leeds match... so I just wanted to ask...

Did anyone else think that these two decisions were inconsistent?

Let me put it this way... the rules changed on try scoring... now, control isn't necessary, downward pressure, without knocking on, is all that matters. APPARENTLY.

As a result, since grounding the ball in your in-goal area is exactly the same process as scoring a try in your opponent's in-goal area, then Mathers did that? The ball is on the ground and there is contact with his fingers. JUST THE SAME as there is for McGuire's try.

To me, the decision should have been either discount both or allow both, as it was the decisions ended up being one of each, resulting in two scores for Leeds.

I mean, it was a thrilling match and everything, and Leeds didn't cheat as such, so take nothing away from them, it wasn't like the blatant offside at Millennium Magic against the Bulls, for instance... but in a game so close it has basically made a massive difference to the table for both teams.

I know we question the ability of officials at the best of times, but I thought this was a particularly bad example. Some tries that have been given via video referee have been awful, probably one of the worst examples was one of Gareth Raynor's, when he CLEARLY knocks on in diving for the ball. Yet the try was given!

So... debate open, chuck in your thoughts or not. It's up to you.

RankPostsTeam
Player Coach3414No
Team
Selected
JoinedServiceReputation
Feb 200718 years
OnlineLast PostLast Page
Jun 2024Aug 2022LINK
Milestone Posts
0
100
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Signature
32137_1302980312.jpg
Fat blokes in the mud, flat caps, bogs that drain pi55 directly onto your boots - Now it's all 'Big Ask', 'Arm Wrestle', 'Collision' 'Contact' 'Facials' 'Upper Body Strength' 'Big Units' 'Scooting from Dummy Half' 'Energy Levels' 'Laying the Platform' ‘Middles’ and 'T-R-Y'. Let’s not forget resilience.:d7dc4b20b2c2dd7b76ac6eac29d5604e_32137.jpg



At normal speed, which by the way is how the game is played, neither Mathers nor McGuire had control, so the first try should have been given and the second try disallowed.

The 'slo-mo' stuff freezes the action to show contact with the fingers and ball and the ground, not control in my book.

No sour grapes as we should have dealt with both. It wasn't Leeds that awarded the TRYs they were awarded by the vieo ref.

RankPostsTeam
Player Coach1341No
Team
Selected
JoinedServiceReputation
Aug 200717 years
OnlineLast PostLast Page
Dec 2011Dec 2011LINK
Milestone Posts
0
100
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Signature
34753_1277062598.gif
[url=http://www.fishsta.co.uk:2vgqqjxt][img:2vgqqjxt]http://img844.imageshack.us/img844/1839/wwwfishstacoukbanner.jpg[/img:2vgqqjxt][/url:2vgqqjxt]:d7dc4b20b2c2dd7b76ac6eac29d5604e_34753.gif



Quote: Big Ask "At normal speed, which by the way is how the game is played, neither Mathers nor McGuire had control, so the first try should have been given and the second try disallowed.

The 'slo-mo' stuff freezes the action to show contact with the fingers and ball and the ground, not control in my book.'"


Yes, that's what I say, no control as such in either case, but certainly downward pressure, albeit very light pressure.

If that is all that's needed, then the opposite decisions to yours should have stood? I.e. No try to Hall and Try to McGuire.

If you need to have control, then as you say, it should be Try to Hall, No Try to McGuire.

Quote: Big Ask "No sour grapes as we should have dealt with both. It wasn't Leeds that awarded the TRYs they were awarded by the vieo ref.'"


Again I agree, and I'm not at all saying that Leeds cheated, just that the decisions as they stood make no sense in the same match, almost as if two completely different policies applied.

I don't mean to confuse things, when I say "The decisions should have matched", I mean that the initial player to contact the ball with ground should have the same decisions applied in each case.

Whichever way you look at it, one try should be given and the other disallowed for the same reason.

RankPostsTeam
Player Coach830No
Team
Selected
JoinedServiceReputation
Nov 200816 years
OnlineLast PostLast Page
Aug 2012Aug 2012LINK
Milestone Posts
0
100
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Signature

:



I agree, if Mcguire didn't think he had control then it is safe to say it probably shouldn't be given. However they are given week in week out. In the same way it should have been judged Matters grounded the ball.

Or perhaps it has something to do with player intentions

RankPostsTeam
Player Coach404No
Team
Selected
JoinedServiceReputation
Feb 200916 years
OnlineLast PostLast Page
Feb 2024Apr 2014LINK
Milestone Posts
0
100
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Signature
43649.jpg
:43649.jpg



Quote: Dawson "Or perhaps it has something to do with player intentions'"


So the VR's have mind reading skills?

RankPostsTeam
Player Coach830No
Team
Selected
JoinedServiceReputation
Nov 200816 years
OnlineLast PostLast Page
Aug 2012Aug 2012LINK
Milestone Posts
0
100
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Signature

:



Quote: Dave Sharky "So the VR's have mind reading skills?'"


Yes

RankPostsTeam
Player Coach124No
Team
Selected
JoinedServiceReputation
Nov 200816 years
OnlineLast PostLast Page
Sep 2012Jul 2012LINK
Milestone Posts
0
100
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Signature
fonds transparents/Sulley.gif
:fonds transparents/Sulley.gif



Quote: Dave Sharky "So the VR's have mind reading skills?'"


Although i felt aggrieved at the decisions at the time - players intentions must be a factor. Mathers was clearly trying to pick up the ball and not ground it (why he didn't kick it dead only he will know!) whereas Mcguire was trying to put downward pressure on the ball albeit only with his fingertips!!!

Similar to when a player sticks a leg out to block a grubber kick if the attacking team picks the ball up tackle count back to zero but if ball hits leg accidently tackle count continues - its all about intent!!

Still miffed that the Hall try was given though!!!

Thats Past - Bring on saturday - cannot wait!!!!

RankPostsTeam
Player Coach4056No
Team
Selected
JoinedServiceReputation
Feb 200718 years
OnlineLast PostLast Page
Mar 2011Mar 2011LINK
Milestone Posts
0
100
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Signature
32034.jpg
:32034.jpg



Both were completely different, Mcguire had his fingers on the ball whilst the ball was on or over the try line. Mathers knocked-on it's that simple, Mathers got his fingertips to the ball then the ball touched the ground but by this time there was daylight between his fingers and the ball hence the reason for a knock-on/play-on and the try was rightly awarded.

RankPostsTeam
Club Owner12214No
Team
Selected
JoinedServiceReputation
Dec 200321 years
OnlineLast PostLast Page
Oct 2021Jun 2017LINK
Milestone Posts
0
100
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Signature
7749_1266928910.jpg
Now The Wire. [quote="Rogues Gallery":xjc47q2r]Wire - the enigma. They could finish top or eighth, who knows.[/quote:xjc47q2r]:d7dc4b20b2c2dd7b76ac6eac29d5604e_7749.jpg



A knock on in the in-goal is a straight drop out isn't it?

RankPostsTeam
Player Coach4056No
Team
Selected
JoinedServiceReputation
Feb 200718 years
OnlineLast PostLast Page
Mar 2011Mar 2011LINK
Milestone Posts
0
100
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Signature
32034.jpg
:32034.jpg



Quote: Lefty "A knock on in the in-goal is a straight drop out isn't it?'"


Oh sorry my mistake it wasn't a knock-on as Mathers was facing his own line and the ball went backwards, it was simply play-on.

RankPostsTeam
Player Coach14129
JoinedServiceReputation
Jun 200618 years
OnlineLast PostLast Page
Nov 2024Nov 2024LINK
Milestone Posts
0
100
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Signature
26249_1542017975.jpg
:d7dc4b20b2c2dd7b76ac6eac29d5604e_26249.jpg



It was one of those fifty-fifty decisions. We would have accepted both decisions in a reciprocal scenario.

But - I don't think players intentions have any course in the decision making process, just the outcome of their actions.

RankPostsTeam
Player Coach141No
Team
Selected
JoinedServiceReputation
Mar 200916 years
OnlineLast PostLast Page
Jun 2010Jun 2010LINK
Milestone Posts
0
100
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Signature
44539.jpg
We're on the march with Tonys army, we're all going to Wembley!!!:44539.jpg



If it was a knock-on wouldn't they have played advantage anyway?

RankPostsTeam
Player Coach14129
JoinedServiceReputation
Jun 200618 years
OnlineLast PostLast Page
Nov 2024Nov 2024LINK
Milestone Posts
0
100
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Signature
26249_1542017975.jpg
:d7dc4b20b2c2dd7b76ac6eac29d5604e_26249.jpg



Quote: Mrs Bridge "If it was a knock-on wouldn't they have played advantage anyway?'"


Yes, if it was an accicental knock-on according to www.therfl.co.uk/~therflc/client ... _2004_.pdf

The only special case is if you knock-on in the oppositions in goal area by accident or knock on deliberately.
Quote: Mrs Bridge "If it was a knock-on wouldn't they have played advantage anyway?'"


Yes, if it was an accicental knock-on according to www.therfl.co.uk/~therflc/client ... _2004_.pdf

The only special case is if you knock-on in the oppositions in goal area by accident or knock on deliberately.


RankPostsTeam
Club Coach4190No
Team
Selected
JoinedServiceReputation
Apr 200520 years
OnlineLast PostLast Page
Apr 2018Jan 2018LINK
Milestone Posts
0
100
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Signature

[quote="Eddie Hemmings said not ":1h9um51j] "Remember last time they were here, the Huddersfield Giants, they lost to a Luke Walsh drop goal. He's only scored four drop goals in his St Helens career has Luke Walsh and each and every one of them have been scored by Luke Walsh"[/quote:1h9um51j]:



McGuire applied intentional downward pressure and the try was correctly given.

Although there was a point where Mathers fingertips were touching the ball and the ball was on the ground he was trying to pick the ball up rather than intentionally grounding the ball hence play on and the try was the correct decision.

Both correct decisions for me.

[iHOWEVER...[/i

I have seen, on many occasions, a player cross the line and either slip, or dummy to ground the ball resulting in an unintentional grounding before they jump up and run under the sticks. The try has then been given where they unintentionally grounded the ball. Now if a try can be given when the attacker unintentionally grounds the ball, shouldn't the same be true for the defender resulting in a drop-out?

RankPostsTeam
Player Coach14129
JoinedServiceReputation
Jun 200618 years
OnlineLast PostLast Page
Nov 2024Nov 2024LINK
Milestone Posts
0
100
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Signature
26249_1542017975.jpg
:d7dc4b20b2c2dd7b76ac6eac29d5604e_26249.jpg



Quote: Thelonius "McGuire applied intentional downward pressure and the try was correctly given.

Although there was a point where Mathers fingertips were touching the ball and the ball was on the ground he was trying to pick the ball up rather than intentionally grounding the ball hence play on and the try was the correct decision.

Both correct decisions for me.

[iHOWEVER...[/i

I have seen, on many occasions, a player cross the line and either slip, or dummy to ground the ball resulting in an unintentional grounding before they jump up and run under the sticks. The try has then been given where they unintentionally grounded the ball. Now if a try can be given when the attacker unintentionally grounds the ball, shouldn't the same be true for the defender resulting in a drop-out?'"



Wrong. The rules do not state a requirement for intention.

Try – How scored 3. A try is scored whengrounds the ball in his opponents’
in-goal, provided that he is not in touch or touch
in-goal or on or over the dead ball line.
(b) opposing players simultaneously ground the ball
in the in-goal area provided that the attacking
player is not in touch or touch in-goal or on or
over the dead ball line.
Sliding try (c) a tackled player’s momentum carries him into the
opponents’ in-goal where he grounds the ball
even if the ball has first touched the ground in the
field of play but provided that when the ball
crosses the goal line the player is not in touch or
touch in-goal or on or over the dead ball line.

GROUNDING means (a) placing the ball on the ground with hand or
THE BALL hands or
(b) exerting a downward pressure on the ball
with hand or arm, the ball itself being on the
ground or
(c) dropping on the ball and covering it with the
part of the body above the waist and below
the neck, the ball itself being on the ground.

17 posts in 2 pages 
<<   PREV  NEXT   >>
17 posts in 2 pages 
<<   PREV  NEXT   >>



All views expressed are those of the author and not necessarily those of the RLFANS.COM or its subsites.

Whilst every effort is made to ensure that news stories, articles and images are correct, we cannot be held responsible for errors. However, if you feel any material on this website is copyrighted or incorrect in any way please contact us using the link at the top of the page so we can remove it or negotiate copyright permission.

RLFANS.COM, the owners of this website, is not responsible for the content of its sub-sites or posts, please email the author of this sub-site or post if you feel you find an article offensive or of a choice nature that you disagree with.

Copyright 1999 - 2024 RLFANS.COM

You must be 18+ to gamble, for more information and for help with gambling issues see https://www.begambleaware.org/.



Please Support RLFANS.COM


4.40283203125:5
RLFANS Recent Posts
FORUM
LAST
POST
TOPIC
POSTER
POSTS
5m
Game - Song Titles
Cokey
40734
6m
BORED The Band Name Game
Cokey
63223
Recent
Film game
Wanderer
5640
FORUM
LAST
VIEW
TOPIC
POSTER
POSTS
15s
Planning for next season
Leyther in n
178
24s
Transfer Talk V5
The Biffs Ba
503
25s
Leeds away first up
Butcher
41
34s
DoR - New Coach - Investor & Adam - New signings
MadDogg
4018
46s
Noah Booth out on loan
Butcher
20
56s
Castleford sack Lingard
FIL
8
59s
Shopping list for 2025
Cokey
5577
1m
Game - Song Titles
Cokey
40734
1m
How many games will we win
Butcher
5
1m
Dons Squad 2025
Jemmo
13
FORUM
NEW
TOPICS
TOPIC
POSTER
POSTS
TODAY
2024
Butcher
5
TODAY
Dan Norman Retires
Cokey
1
TODAY
How many games will we win
Butcher
5
TODAY
Leigh Leopards - 2025 Fixtures
ColD
2
TODAY
Catalan Away
jonh
5
TODAY
2025 Betfred Super League Fixtures
RLFANS News
1
TODAY
2025 fixtures
Smiffy27
15
TODAY
Fixtures
Willzay
13
TODAY
Salford
rubber ducki
12
TODAY
WCC Off
Choc Ice
11
TODAY
Leeds away first up
Butcher
41
TODAY
Jake McLoughlin
Wanderer
1
TODAY
Assistant Coach - Langley
exiledrhino
30
TODAY
Noah Booth out on loan
Butcher
20
TODAY
Luke Gale testimonial match
BarnsleyGull
2
TODAY
England 5 - 0 Ireland
Sadfish
1
TODAY
Magic Weekend 2025 - Back To Newcastle
RLFANS News
1
NEWS ITEMS
VIEWS
2025 Betfred Super League Fixt..
492
Magic Weekend 2025 - Back To N..
533
England Beat Samoa To Take Tes..
1276
England's Women Demolish The W..
1100
England Beat Samoa Comfortably..
1343
Operational Rules Tribunal –..
1133
IMG-RFL club gradings released..
1400
Wakefield Trinity Win Champion..
1933
Hunslet Secure Promotion After..
2151
Trinity Into Play Off Final Af..
2391
Wigan Warriors Crowned Champio..
1960
York Valkyrie Win Back to Back..
2198
Hunslet Book Relegation Play O..
2661
Penrith Panthers Secure Fourth..
2093
Wigan Humiliate Leigh For Gran..
2166
POSTSONLINEREGISTRATIONSRECORD
19.65M 1,986 80,15514,103
LOGIN HERE
or REGISTER for more features!.

When you register you get access to the live match scores, live match chat and you can post in the discussions on the forums.
RLFANS Match Centre
 Thu 13th Feb 2025
     Mens Super League XXX-R1
20:00
Wigan
v
Leigh
 Fri 14th Feb 2025
     Mens Super League XXX-R1
20:00
Hull KR
v
Castleford
20:00
Catalans
v
Hull FC
 Sat 15th Feb 2025
     Mens Super League XXX-R1
15:00
Leeds
v
Wakefield
17:30
St.Helens
v
Salford
 Sun 16th Feb 2025
     Mens Super League XXX-R1
15:00
Huddersfield
v
Warrington
 Thu 20th Feb 2025
     Mens Super League XXX-R2
20:00
Wakefield
v
Hull KR
 Fri 21st Feb 2025
     Mens Super League XXX-R2
20:00
Warrington
v
Catalans
20:00
Hull FC
v
Wigan
 Sat 22nd Feb 2025
     Mens Super League XXX-R2
15:00
Salford
v
Leeds
20:00
Castleford
v
St.Helens
 Sun 23rd Feb 2025
     Mens Super League XXX-R2
14:30
Leigh
v
Huddersfield
 Thu 6th Mar 2025
     Mens Super League XXX-R3
20:00
Hull FC
v
Leigh
 Fri 7th Mar 2025
     Mens Super League XXX-R3
20:00
Castleford
v
Salford
20:00
St.Helens
v
Hull KR
 Sat 8th Mar 2025
     Mens Super League XXX-R3
17:30
Catalans
v
Leeds
 Sun 9th Mar 2025
     Mens Super League XXX-R3
17:30
Warrington
v
Wakefield
17:30
Wigan
v
Huddersfield
 Thu 20th Mar 2025
     Mens Super League XXX-R4
20:00
Salford
v
Huddersfield
 Fri 21st Mar 2025
     Mens Super League XXX-R4
20:00
St.Helens
v
Warrington
ALL SCORES PROVIDED BY RLFANS.COM (SETTINGS)
Matches on TV
Thu 13th Feb
SL
20:00
Wigan-Leigh
Fri 14th Feb
SL
20:00
Hull KR-Castleford
SL
20:00
Catalans-Hull FC
Sat 15th Feb
SL
15:00
Leeds-Wakefield
SL
17:30
St.Helens-Salford
Sun 16th Feb
SL
15:00
Huddersfield-Warrington
Thu 20th Feb
SL
20:00
Wakefield-Hull KR
Fri 21st Feb
SL
20:00
Warrington-Catalans
SL
20:00
Hull FC-Wigan
Sat 22nd Feb
SL
15:00
Salford-Leeds
SL
20:00
Castleford-St.Helens
Sun 23rd Feb
SL
14:30
Leigh-Huddersfield
Thu 6th Mar
SL
20:00
Hull FC-Leigh
Fri 7th Mar
SL
20:00
Castleford-Salford
SL
20:00
St.Helens-Hull KR
Sat 8th Mar
SL
17:30
Catalans-Leeds
Sun 9th Mar
SL
17:30
Warrington-Wakefield
SL
17:30
Wigan-Huddersfield
Thu 20th Mar
SL
20:00
Salford-Huddersfield
Fri 21st Mar
SL
20:00
St.Helens-Warrington
This is an inplay table and live positions can change.
Mens Betfred Super League XXVIII ROUND : 1
 PLDFADIFFPTS
Wigan 29 768 338 430 48
Hull KR 29 731 344 387 44
Warrington 29 769 351 418 42
Leigh 29 580 442 138 33
Salford 28 556 561 -5 32
St.Helens 28 618 411 207 30
 
Catalans 27 475 427 48 30
Leeds 27 530 488 42 28
Huddersfield 27 468 658 -190 20
Castleford 27 425 735 -310 15
Hull FC 27 328 894 -566 6
LondonB 27 317 916 -599 6
This is an inplay table and live positions can change.
Betfred Championship 2024 ROUND : 1
 PLDFADIFFPTS
Wakefield 27 1032 275 757 52
Toulouse 26 765 388 377 37
Bradford 28 723 420 303 36
York 29 695 501 194 32
Widnes 27 561 502 59 29
Featherstone 27 634 525 109 28
 
Sheffield 26 626 526 100 28
Doncaster 26 498 619 -121 25
Halifax 26 509 650 -141 22
Batley 26 422 591 -169 22
Swinton 28 484 676 -192 20
Barrow 25 442 720 -278 19
Whitehaven 25 437 826 -389 18
Dewsbury 27 348 879 -531 4
Hunslet 1 6 10 -4 0
RLFANS Recent Posts
FORUM
LAST
POST
TOPIC
POSTER
POSTS
5m
Game - Song Titles
Cokey
40734
6m
BORED The Band Name Game
Cokey
63223
Recent
Film game
Wanderer
5640
FORUM
LAST
VIEW
TOPIC
POSTER
POSTS
15s
Planning for next season
Leyther in n
178
24s
Transfer Talk V5
The Biffs Ba
503
25s
Leeds away first up
Butcher
41
34s
DoR - New Coach - Investor & Adam - New signings
MadDogg
4018
46s
Noah Booth out on loan
Butcher
20
56s
Castleford sack Lingard
FIL
8
59s
Shopping list for 2025
Cokey
5577
1m
Game - Song Titles
Cokey
40734
1m
How many games will we win
Butcher
5
1m
Dons Squad 2025
Jemmo
13
FORUM
NEW
TOPICS
TOPIC
POSTER
POSTS
TODAY
2024
Butcher
5
TODAY
Dan Norman Retires
Cokey
1
TODAY
How many games will we win
Butcher
5
TODAY
Leigh Leopards - 2025 Fixtures
ColD
2
TODAY
Catalan Away
jonh
5
TODAY
2025 Betfred Super League Fixtures
RLFANS News
1
TODAY
2025 fixtures
Smiffy27
15
TODAY
Fixtures
Willzay
13
TODAY
Salford
rubber ducki
12
TODAY
WCC Off
Choc Ice
11
TODAY
Leeds away first up
Butcher
41
TODAY
Jake McLoughlin
Wanderer
1
TODAY
Assistant Coach - Langley
exiledrhino
30
TODAY
Noah Booth out on loan
Butcher
20
TODAY
Luke Gale testimonial match
BarnsleyGull
2
TODAY
England 5 - 0 Ireland
Sadfish
1
TODAY
Magic Weekend 2025 - Back To Newcastle
RLFANS News
1
NEWS ITEMS
VIEWS
2025 Betfred Super League Fixt..
492
Magic Weekend 2025 - Back To N..
533
England Beat Samoa To Take Tes..
1276
England's Women Demolish The W..
1100
England Beat Samoa Comfortably..
1343
Operational Rules Tribunal –..
1133
IMG-RFL club gradings released..
1400
Wakefield Trinity Win Champion..
1933
Hunslet Secure Promotion After..
2151
Trinity Into Play Off Final Af..
2391
Wigan Warriors Crowned Champio..
1960
York Valkyrie Win Back to Back..
2198
Hunslet Book Relegation Play O..
2661
Penrith Panthers Secure Fourth..
2093
Wigan Humiliate Leigh For Gran..
2166


Visit the RLFANS.COM SHOP
for more merchandise!