I think you will find they would.

Tomkins is world class.
If we had two half backs in his class we might have a chance but, as it is, I do not think so.
I would have loved to see him in P&B because, after all, The Wire were his boyhood team. In spite of the media saying he is a Wiganer

By "we" I mean England not the Wire.

World class? Slater is world class, Tomkins is nowhere near!

He's cack under the high ball, not as solid/reliable in defence as Wellens and Radlinski used to be, doesn't make as many clean breaks as people think he does or should, mouths off and whinges at the ref all game.

The only thing he has that you would say he is good at is he is a good runner in broken play - but only done that in SL against some mediocre defences. In the international game, he's just not doing it cos he's not good enough.

Don't get me wrong, he's better than anything else England have, but if he's the best then it really does prove how far away we are in the talent pool to Aus and NZ.

Exactly my point, well said, now lets see how he performs next year, if he does well in the NRL I will eat my words and congratulate him, but in the meantime, let's all get a life!

How very dare you, Eddie & Stevo would vomit upon reading this

2nd in the English team for clean breaks, 2nd for metres made, most try assists, 1 missed tackle, second for tackle busts.

Looks o.k to me.

He'll do well in the NRL.

3rd for clean breaks - 13th overall in the whole comp.

9th overall for metres made

2nd overall for try assists

10th overall for tackle busts ( even a welshman is above him! )

6th overall in errors made ( and how many players in the entire tournament?? )

So, for the most expensive player in the world, not great stats I don't think. Not exactly set the WC on fire has he!!

Other than the reference to Wellens and Radlinski ar eyou talking about briers here?

Why are you bringing Briers into it? We're talking about Tomkins.

So Warrington fans think Tomkins is a poor player.
Says it all really!

good player yes world class no..slater thurston now they are world class...

Who has said he is poor?

Let's rave about how good he is on Saturday once he's beaten NZ on his own! Whilst he's some player within the world of Super League the true test will be when he plays in the NRL against quality opposition week in week out. Credit to him he's put his hand up to go so he must back himself.
Shame he was sinbinned for the last 7 or so minutes at the DW on his last game there

we are really scraping the barrel in this thread, its embarrassing