Pretty much spot on.

Genuine question - When does the goodwill that Tony Smith has garnered through his great work during his early years, eventually run out?

We've been in steady decline since 2011 - Compare the first choice 17's from then and now. Only Chris Hill would make the 2011 team. Those players whose names make both line ups have gone downhill since then, our signings since that time have been mediocre, and the young players coming through, while decent enough, none are what you would call quality.

I'm not saying Smith should be sacked or anything, but if this decline continues, by the end of his contract in 2016, most of us will be quite happy to see the back of him.

4pm, Monday 6th April, Luke Dorn interception try...

Best fans in Super League? We gave Paul Cullen 6 years at the helm now some are questioning arguably our best manager since WWII after 3 bad results ?

You really hate it when anybodies opinion is different to yours.

By your opinion nobody but nobody can criticise Smith because of what he's done. We'll all be eternally grateful for that.

Well in the here and now this coach and this team are hurtling towards possible middle tier rugby, then facing a battle to stay in SuperLeague.

I'm sorry that you feel that a coach appears unable or unwilling to see what's happening in front of him is beyond reproach.

Bit banal childish jibes are hardly the actions of a lucid person are they?

Only you and rubber duckie pal. Only you two.....

On a serious note for me to agree with your point of view I would have to think
A)You can see half back problems and Tony Smith can't. .

You'll forgive me if I side with Tony Smith I don't know your rugby league background. .Please tell us....

B)I'd have to agree a 22 year old player fresh from his only other club is stealing a living.....

Your not on I'll agree he's out of form but stealing a living no way. ..

There are probably more about Agar but seriously how can anyone know what an assistant does. ...when poaching left people said all he did was put the cones out. ....

So come on talk sensible rugby and not tittle tattle and i might agree with you.

Your at it again.

So how long does Tony Smith's untouchable period last then?... I am genuinely interested to know.

Like I say, I don't want to see him sacked, or see any campaign to oust him, but I'm just curious how many years 3 challenge cups (last of which was 3 years ago) actually earns a man, before people can openly question his PRESENT performance without being shouted down as some sort of knee-jerk reactionary??

I was simply stating that if the obvious decline continues at the present rate, by the end of the 2016 season, people might have to eventually wake up and stop believing that Smith is some type of demi-God.

To be honest I'm not asking for you to agree not belittle a point of view.

A) the half back problems needed to be addressed and haven't. If he does see it, then why doesn't he do something about it. At present trying Dec Patton could not possibly do any worse than we're doing at present. Again and in my opinion Smith seems a lot more disinterested than ever. Perhaps he's planning his exit route, hence Agar appointment. But you have to agree something radical needs doing at half back.

B) Clark was fairly open on his first interview with the comment about hope to win things in the two years I'm here. I know news signed for 4, but that's what he said. Be is playing completely disinterested and is at present is just doing what any other hooker would do, ship it on.

Again in my opinion if something drastic is not done we're in big trouble

Willie poaching seems to be doing quite well at Hull Kr puttin the cones out, I must say!

Boys and girls have a bit of patience, I think things will improve when we go full time.

Just wait until we move into the new stadium !