That's why I wrote 'arguably' or perhaps you missed that in your rage.

Have a lie down yourself and READ THE POST

When Matt King's Cat said "arguably" my guess was that it was recognition that you (the reader, not you specifically) may, or may not, share that opinion.

It wasn't an invitation for a laughing fit by the hard of thinking ?!?!?!?!!!!!!****!!!!!

FWIW I think that it would be hard to place Monaghan over the whole SL era, but, there's not many on here that would have swapped him for A N Other during his time with us...top drawer 9

Interesting way of classifying a player by his medal haul. I suppose we would have to rate Ryan Bailey as the worlds best ever prop since he has won 6 GF's. And you would have to question Smiths sanity after we released Chris Riley with his 3 CC medals.

You don't need to look at medals to know Monaghan shouldn't be in the same sentence as many of the hookers mentioned - just use your eyes.

Many? I'll give you Roby and Cunningham but that's it. Monas was top drawer...streets ahead of diskin and newton and just ahead of lowes imo.

Lowes was much better. Newton was a better hooker at his best as well. Swain and Buderus to go with Roby and Cunningham also.

That's six off the top of my head.

Buderus whilst in sl??? Stay off the Alcopops son

Son

Buderus put in a performance in the 2011 Grand Final that Monaghan hasn't reached in his entire time here.

You have Monaghan, the rest of us will stick with what we've had.......I doubt you'll hear many complaints

Monaghan was the best ref out of all of them

There isn't a single facet of the hooking role in which Monaghan outshone Keiron Cunningham.

You guys are all comedians. There's a reason Monaghan was at Warrington much of his career - he wasn't very good.

Come on lads, he's obviously on the wind up.

Can't remember cunningham having a great kicking game