Agree, as much as I like Atkins he needs to be dropped!

I have the strangest feeling we will win one trophy this year for sure. I think Smith will rise to the challenge of sorting our team out.

Seeing as this is the negative thread.

Asotasi still hasn't shown enough in which I can justifiably say he was worth bringing in OVER Carvell and Morley.

He's not been bad but i think he's weaker than both Gaz and Moz.

Still slightly disturbed at his comments about this being a bit of a holiday, 100% committed or look for your pay cheque elsewhere

Asotasi looks more like a 2nd row to me, to be honest. He played ok, but he certainly doesn't look to be as damaging a runner as Chris Hill, for example. Also, has anyone noticed how few offloads we've been doing so far? I know Harrison and Carvell were two leading exponents but we appear to be playing under orders to keep it conservative, which is at odds with our usual ethos.

Asotasi defo prob morrisseyisawire.
He aint dynamic enough as a backrower.
He was solid. Without starring. I think both sets of props equalled themselves out tonight.
I would guess they all put in around the same amount of tackling and yardages.

I've said before that I think Leeds ate the best team in the comp this year. Good effort from our pack and I expect to see them dominant other teams and see Asotasi looking more mobile.

If we didn't have Atkins making all those mistakes and Leeds didnt have Jamie peacock doing all those tackles we'd have won. I'm not as doom mongered as I was last week.

We had plenty of possession on the Leeds line more than they had on ours I thought.

dissapointed in Myler, O'Brien was superb. the props were ok, no standouts and they pretty much matched the Leeds pack imo.

Obviously Atkins stunk like an open sewer that's my only bit of doom.